About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



14 U. Pa. J. Const. L. 485 (2011-2012)
Science or Stigma: Potential Challenges to the FDA's Ban on Gay Blood

handle is hein.journals/upjcl14 and id is 489 raw text is: COMMENTS

SCIENCE OR STIGMA: POTENTIAL CHALLENGES TO THE FDA's
BAN ON GAY BLOOD
Dwaynej. Bensing
I. INTRODUCTION
There is a great need for blood in the United States.' Each year,
4.5 million Americans will need a blood transfusion.! The American
Association of Blood Banks (AABB) estimates that 10.8 million volun-
teers donate blood each year, less than ten percent of the eligible
donors.    The great need for blood, coupled with the small pool of
donors, has resulted in blood shortages thatjeopardize the execution
of medical procedures. The blood supply in the United States has
reached a breaking point.
* J.D. Candidate, 2012, University of Pennsylvania Law School, B.A., 2007 University of Ar-
kansas. Special thanks to Professor Sophia Z. Lee for her guidance in this process and to
my partner, Christopher R. Howland, who provided feedback and encouragement.
1   See, e.g., Blood FAQ AABB, http://www.aabb.org/iesources/bct/Pages/bloodfaq.aspx
(last visited Oct. 24, 2011) (Every day in the U.S., approximately 44,000 units of blood
are required in hospitals and emergency treatment facilities for patients with cancer and
other diseases, for organ transplant recipients, and to help save the lives of acci-
dent/trauma victims. In 2008, more than twenty-three million blood components were
transfused. And with an aging population and advances in medical treatments and pro-
cedures requiring blood transfusions, the demand for blood continues to increase.).
2   56  Facts About Blood, AM.'s   BLoOD   CTRS., http://www.americasblood.org/
go.cfm?do=page.view&pid=12 (last visited Oct. 24, 2011).
3   See AABB, supra note I (stating that AABB estimates that 10.8 million volunteers donate
blood each year and that less than 10 percent of the U.S. population eligible to do-
nate blood at any given time actually do so).
4   See Ishani Ganguli, Blood Shortage Puts Safety Measures in Question, REUTERS (Sept. 10, 2007,
10:23  AM), http://www.ieuters.com/article/2007/09/ 10/us-usa-health-blood-idUSN
0642622220070910?pageNumber-=1 (noting that American blood banks experienced
one of their driest summers in history and that [iun Washington's Georgetown Universi-
ty Hospital, officials came close to canceling nonemergency operations several times this
summer).
5   See Red Cross Blood Suptply Dr4s to Critically Low Levels, AM. RED CROSS (July 11, 2011),
http://www.redcross.org/portal/site/en/menuitem.94aae335470e233f6cf91ldf43181aaO
/?vgnextoid=2b24ae4376dOl3OVgnVCM10000089fO87OaRCRD (stating that the Ameri-
can Red Cross issued an appeal for blood donors to roll up a sleeve and address a critical
shortage across the nation).

485