About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



30 U. Cin. L. Rev. 35 (1961)
Bigamy, a Crime Though Unwittingly Committed

handle is hein.journals/ucinlr30 and id is 47 raw text is: BIGAMY, A CRIME THOUGH UNWITTINGLY
COMMITTED
MARVIN M. MOORE *
In most American jurisdictions it is the law that criminal
intent is unnecessary to the crime of bigamy. Whether or not
the accused knew that he was already married when he wedded
his second spouse is deemed an immaterial issue. This law cannot
be vindicated, as will, it is hoped, become evident in the follow-
ing paragraphs. The rule's existence and wide acceptance are
ascribable primarily to three factors: historical considerations;
judicial deference to certain principles of statutory construction;
and, misguided judical concepts of public policy.
To treat first of its historical development, bigamy became a
crime in England during the reign of James I,1 when a statute
was passed entitled, lengthily enough, An Act to Restrain All
Persons from Marriage Until Their Former Wives and Former
Husbands Be Dead. The act's preamble read thus:
Forasmuch as divers evil disposed persons, being married,
run out of one country into another, or into places where they
are not known, and there become to be married, having an-
other husband or wife living, to the great dishonor of God
and the utter undoing of divers honest men's children and
others, be it enacted by the King's Majesty as follows .... 2
The phrase to the great dishonor of God is significant, for
at this time the feeling was widespread that to commit bigamy
was to profane a solemn ceremony, and the offense was conse-
*Assistant Professor of Law, University of Akron College of Law. A. B.,
Wayne State University. L.L.B. and L.L.M., Duke University.
I Prior to this time bigamy constituted merely a minor offense punishable
by ecclesiastical courts. State v. Sellers, 140 S.C. 66, 134 S.E. 873 (1926).
However, anyone guilty of the act was prohibited from ever taking ecclesiastical
orders and was denied benefit of clergy. Trowbridge, Criminal Intent and Bigamy,
7 CAuF. L. REV. 1, 10 (1918).
22 James I, c. 11 (1604). See Bartholomew, The Origin and Development of
the Law of Bigamy, 74 L.Q. REv. 259 (1958).