About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



25 Tocqueville Rev. 77 (2004)
Affirmative Action and Positive Discrimination

handle is hein.journals/tocqvr25 and id is 77 raw text is: The Tocqueville Review/La Revue Tocqueville, Vol. XY, n 1 - 2004

AFFIRMATIVE ACTION AND POSITIVE DISCRIMINATION
Daniel DiSALvo & James W. CEASER
A specter is haunting France and America. It is known alternatively as
discrimination positive or affirmative action. The concept refers to
policies that legitimate the use of measures that explicitly take into
account an individual's group status in the allocation of jobs, contracts,
and university admissions to assist groups that are disadvantaged and that
have suffered historically from discrimination. According to its
proponents, the larger objectives of these policies include eliminating
patterns of negative discrimination, producing greater equality, integrating
members of these groups into society by giving them a larger stake in it,
and achieving greater representativeness or diversity. Yet, the concept of
discrimination positive or affirmative action has generated enormous
controversy and opposition in both societies. It violates, many insist, a
fundamental principle of what the French call r publicanisme and
Americans call liberalism: the awarding of positions and benefits on the
basis of colorblind (non-ascriptive) and, where applicable, meritocratic
criteria.
Although the basic meaning of the concept is roughly the same in both
societies, the status of the policy in the two countries is vastly different.
Affirmative action has now been in effect in the United States, in some
form, for four decades. It has been extensively debated, litigated, and
studied. Hundreds of scholars and journalists have addressed one aspect