About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



8 LBJ J. Pub. Aff. 26 (1996)
When Goals Diverge: Social Security Reform in Mexico

handle is hein.journals/lbjalopua8 and id is 28 raw text is: BY NoRRIs COCHRAN
Norris Cochran is a third-year stu-
dent in the joint LBI/Latin American
Studies program. He received his
Bachelor ofArts degree in History of
Public Policy from the University of
California at Santa Barbara in 1993.
His interests include domestic and
international health, environmental
policy and foreign diplomacy. He
served as an intern during the sum-
mer of 1995 researching the health
sector in Mexico at the U.S. Embassy
in Mexico City.

WHEN GOALS
DIVERGE:
SOCIAL SECURITY REFORM IN MEXICO
DEMOGRAPHIC CHANGES ARE COMPELLING MEXICO
to abandon pay-as-you-go financing for its
social security system. As Mexico wrestles
with the development of a new and equitable sys-
tem, it is confronting problems certain to arise in
other countries. What lessons does the Mexican
experience teach us?
Early in the morning on December 8, 1995, after a long evening of heated
debate, the Mexican Chamber of Deputies approved a law to reform the
national social security pension system. The issue was politically sensi-
tive, and the scale of the proposed changes ensured that the voting was
close. The new Social Security Law (Ley del Seguro Social, LSS) was
pushed through by the ruling party and passed by a narrow majority
along party lines.'
As Mexico passes subsequent legislation and begins the arduous pro-
cess of implementation, the reform is not going unnoticed. Financial ana-
lysts and potential investors are watching closely as a new system of fully
funded pensions promises to deepen financial markets in Mexico and
create capital for investment in the domestic economy. Policy makers in
other Latin American nations and the developing world will be keenly
interested in the reform. Old age and retirement pensions are often the
only bulwark between a sustainable lifestyle and crushing poverty for
millions of people in the developing world. Since the 1980s, nations
around the globe have begun to reevaluate their social security systems
and have sought to transform them from inefficient drains on the public
coffers to streamlined providers of social assistance and generators of
domestic savings. The reform in Mexico is likely to succeed, and, conse-
quently, is attracting attention.
The Mexican Institute of Social Security (Instituto Mexicano del Seguro
Social, IMSS), the nation's general social security provider and the focus

LBJ JoURNAL OF PUBLIC AFFAIRS