About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



101 Ky. L.J. 207 (2012-2013)
Ecclesia Semper Reformanda Est: Radical Reformation and the IRS

handle is hein.journals/kentlj101 and id is 215 raw text is: Ecclesia Semper Reformanda Est.
Radical Reformation and the IRS
Mason Powell
What is a 'church'for purposes of the statute must be interpreted in
the light of the common understanding of the word.
-De La Salle Institute v. United States'
My good Erasmus, God's church is not so common a
thing as the term 'God's church'. ...
-Martin Luther, The Bondage of the WilP
INTRODUCTION
H ERE'S the church/here's the steeple/open the doors/and see all the people/here
is the parson going upstairs/and here he is saying his prayers. This simple
children's rhyme has been taught in churches and Sunday schools around
the world for many years to impress upon toddlers a basic understanding of
the church. It comes complete with hand motions that illustrate the verses:
fingers pointed upwards for a steeple, folded hands for prayer, wiggling
fingers that represent all the people (everyone's favorite part, of course).
Yet for its simplicity, the toddler's rhyme attempts to address complex
questions that have troubled many grownups for a very long time.4
Here's the church. What makes something a church? Perhaps a church is
a steeple and doors-a building. After all, it certainly seems that the droves
of ordinary churches and religious groups with which we are familiar
tend to reside within a distinctive physical structure of some sort. When
we see the ornately ornamented buttresses of a cathedral or the towering
minarets of a mosque, we instantly know to identify them as housing a
given religious denomination. But there must be more to a church than
steeples and doors. Surely there must be people, but how many? What type
of people must these people be, and what sort of things must these people
I Mason Powell is a J.D. candidate for May 2013 and Notes Editor for the Kentucky Law
Journal. He holds a B.A. in Theology and Biblical Studies from Boyce College of the Southern
Baptist Theological Seminary.
2 De La Salle Inst. v. United States, 195 E Supp. 891, 903 (N.D. Cal. 1961).
3 MARTIN LUTHER, THE BONDAGE OF THE WILL 122 (J.I. Packer & O.R. Johnston trans.,
Fleming H. Revell rev. ed. 2005).
4 See, e.g., Charles M. Whelan, Church in the Internal Revenue Code: The Definitional Prob-
lems, 45 FORDHAM L. REV. 885,887 (1977).