About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



59 Colum. L. Rev. 1115 (1959)
Delay and the Dynamics of Personal Injury Litigation

handle is hein.journals/clr59 and id is 1145 raw text is: ,COLUMBIA LAW                                                  REVIEW
Vol. 59                            DECEMBER      1959                            No. 8
DELAY AND THE DYNAMICS OF PERSONAL
INJURY LITIGATION
MAURICE ROSENBERG* and MICHAEL I. SOVERNt
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PAGE
I.  THE  PROBLEM   .........................................................     1116
II.  SOURCES  OF  DATA ......................................................     1118
III. How BAD IS DELAY IN NEW YORK CITY? .............................. 1121
IV. AN APPROACH TO THE PROBLEM: THE CRUCIAL 7,000 .................... 1124
V. CHARACTERISTICS OF TRIAL-BOUND CASES ................................ 1126
A .  Size  ..............................................................    1127
1.  Suits  and  size ..................................................  1127
2.  Trials  and  size ..................................................  1130
3.  Verdicts  and  size ...............................................  1136
4.  Delay  and  size ..................................................  1137
B. Involvement of an Extra Attorney or Firm ........................ 1139
1. Suits and extra attorneys ........................................ 1139
2. Trials and extra attorneys ....................................... 1140
3. Delay and extra attorneys ....................................... 1140
C.  Presence  of a  Lien ..................................................  1141
1.  Suits  and  liens ..................................................  1142
2.  Trials  and  liens .................................................  1143
3.  Verdicts  and  liens ...............................................  1144
4.  Delay  and  liens .................................................  1144
VI. VARIATIONS AMONG COURTS ............................................ 1145
A. Comparative Delay ................................................ 1145
B. Comparative Percentages of Trials .................................. 1149
C. Comparative Percentages of Complete Trials ........................ 1150
VII. SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION ............................................ 1151
APPENDIX A: Closing Statement as to Retainer ............................... 1157
APPENDIX B: Accounting for Missing Cases-Would Total Compliance with.
the Closing Statement Rule Alter the Findingsf ................ 1158
APPENDIX C: Sources and Methods in Estimating          the Volume of Personal
Injury Claims and Suits in New    York City .................... 1160
1. The Proportion of Suits Reaching Trial .................... 1161
2. The Proportion of Cases That Are Sued .................... 1163
3. The Proportion of Trials Going to Verdict .................. 1164
APPENDIX D: The Extent and Effect of Concentration of Personal Injury Cases
in the Hands of Specialist Attorneys and Firms ............... 1166
APPENDIX E: A      Demonstration That Cases Do Not Appreciate Substantially
in Value as a Result of Going to Trial .......................... 1169
Professor of Law, Columbia University; Director, Columbia University Project
for Effective Justice.
t Associate Professor of Law, Columbia University; Associate Director, Columbia
University Project for Effective Justice (1959-1960). For their devoted efforts in collect-
ing and evaluating the data that this article presents, we are deeply indebted to a number
of associates in the Project's-work. In 1957-1958, Dr. Irving Mark was in charge