About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



30 U. Tol. L. Rev. 1 (1998-1999)
Fundamentally Speaking Application of Ohio's Domestic Violence Laws in Parental Discipline Cases - A Parental Perspective

handle is hein.journals/utol30 and id is 13 raw text is: FUNDAMENTALLY SPEAKING- APPLICATION OF
OHIO'S DOMESTIC VIOLENCE LAWS IN PARENTAL
DISCIPLINE CASES-A PARENTAL PERSPECTIVE
Richard Garner
INTRODUCTION
F EW subjects rouse our emotions more than the question of what constitutes
proper care for our children. And in that context, there is likely no more hotly
contested issue than the use of corporal discipline. Philosophies vary widely
on the practice. Proponents and opponents offer scientific, legal, and metaphysical
argu-ments for their respective positions. The opinion cacophony generally has little
practical impact upon the average family This changes, however, where one side or
the other is able to engineer statements of positive law Philosophical opponents of
corporal discipline may have accomplished just that by harnessing a hitherto
unrealized power of Ohio s domestic violence laws.
Domestic violence laws are of relative recent vintage m Ohio.' Social, legal, and
political forces converged in 1979 to clarify existing assault and battery laws and to
adopt more effective legal procedures to reduce violence between family and
household members. The impetus behind such laws has been examined by many
authors.2 Although written broadly, the principal focus of domestic violence laws
* Magistrate, Delaware Municipal Court, 1997 to present. Assistant Prosecutor, Delaware City
Prosecutor's Office, 1993-1997 B.A., Ohio State University (1990); J.D., Ohio State University
(1993). Father and husband.
1. Ohio's original domestic violence legislation was enacted in 1979 (HB 835). It included both
civil and criminal provisions. Oio REV. CODE ANN. § 2919.25 (West 1994). Section 2919.25 is the
primary criminal provision which prohibits: (A) knowingly causing or attempting to cause physical
harm to a family or household member; (B) recklessly causing serious physical harm to a family or
household member; and (C) knowingly, by threat of force, causing a family or household member to
believe that the offender will cause imminent physical harm to the family or household member.
Sections 2919.25(A) and (B) are essentially restatements of Ohio's criminal assault statute, OIo REV
CODE ANN. § 2903.13 (West 1994). Section 2919.25(C) is a derivation of Ohio's menacing statute,
OHIO REV CODE ANN. § 2903.22 (West 1994). Violation of sections 2919.25(A) or (B) is a
misdemeanor of the first defree aunishable by un to six months in iail and/or un to a S 1.000 fine. OHIO
REV. CODE ANN. § 2919.25(A)-(B) (West 1994). Subsequent violations can enhance the status to a
felony of the fourth degree. OioREV. CODE ANN. § 2919.25(D) (West 1994). Violation of section
(C) is a misdemeanor of the fourth degree punishable by up to thirty days in jail and/or up to a $250
fine. OmO REV CODE ANN. § 2919.25(C) (West 1994). Subsequent violations can enhance to a
misdemeanor of the third degree. OinoiREV CODEANN. § 2919.25(D) (West 1994). H.B. 835 also
created both criminal and civil protection orders for victims of domestic violence. OHO REV. CODE
ANN. § 2919.26-.271; OIo REV CODE ANN. § 3113.31(C)(West 1994).
2. See, e.g., Nancy E. Grim, Domestic Relations: Legal Responses to Wife Beating; Theory and
Practice in Ohio, 16 AKRON L. REV. 705 (1983); Daisy Quarm & Martin D. Schwartz, Legal Reform
and the Criminal Court: The Case of Domestic Violence, 10 N. KY. L. REV 199 (1983); Sarah M.
Ramsey Ohio's Domestic Violence Law, 8 Otuo N.U. L. REV. 895 (1981); Ralph 0. Anderson,
Comment, Spouse Battering and Ohio's Domestic Violence Legislation, 13 U. TOL. L. REV 347 (1982);
Mark R. Chilson, Note, HB 835: Ohio's Response to the Domestic Violence Dilemma, 5 U. DAYTON
L. REV 427 (1980).