About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



4 NUJS L. Rev. 83 (2011)
Rent Control in India - Obstacles for Urban Reform

handle is hein.journals/nujslr4 and id is 83 raw text is: RENT CONTROL IN INDIA - OBSTACLES
FOR URBAN REFORM
Aditya Alok & Pankti Vora*
Rent Control has been one of the foremost welfare measures that have
survived in India. The governments ofvarious countries have tried from
time to time to make sure the laws are apt to meet the requirements. In
the first decade ofthe 2t century, however, rent control has been seen as
an obstacle to urban reforms. The paper takes a look at the extant legal
regime and the proposed changes. It needs to be noted that the proposed
reform was introduced in the form of the Model Rent Control Legislation
in 1992, yet only five states have implemented the same. The only upside
is that about ten states have proposed bills as of 2010. In the course of
this paper we attempt to analyse as to what extent the proposed changes
tackle the problems faced under the extant regime. Further, in light of
the examples put forth by the existing states that have implemented new
age laws, we seek to suggest improvements.
I. INTRODUCTION
As in several other countries, rent control has been used
in India as a tool of welfare governance. Though legislations have existed
since pre-independence times, the Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal
Mission ('JNNURM')' has made rent control a contentious issue. JNNURM
sees these legislations as an urban bottleneck that needs reform.2
Rent control in India was introduced to prevent pseudo-scar-
city of rental housing post-World War II. The legislations allowed for requi-
sitioning houses lying vacant in tenantable conditions. Although introduced
as a temporary measure, rent control legislations have somehow continued as
a policy decision. Conditions that demanded these legislations have changed.
 d3 and 1 year students respectively, B.A. LL.B. (Hons.), the W.B. National University of
Juridical Sciences, Kolkata.
Ministry of Urban Development, Government of India, JNNURM, Sub-Mission I (Urban
Infrastructure & Governance), available at http:/.innurm.nic.in/nurmudwAeb/defaultud.aspx,
(Last visited on August 29, 2010).
Dr. Manmohan Singh, JAURAI: A New Vision fior the Future of Urban India, Economic
Developments in India (Raj & Uma Kapila, eds.), 18, Vol. 144, Academic Foundation, New
Delhi, 2009.

January - March, 2011