About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



3 Ky. J. Equine Agric. & Nat. Resources L. 121 (2010-2011)
U.S. v. Bailey: An Expansion of Federal Clean Water Act Jurisdiction

handle is hein.journals/kjequinan3 and id is 123 raw text is: U.S. V. BAILEY: AN EXPANSION OF FEDERAL CLEAN WATER
ACT JURISDICTION
ANTHONY CASH*
I. INTRODUCTION
It is easier to seek forgiveness than permission. While this widely
quoted piece of cynical wisdom holds true in many cases, an attorney must
often give the opposite advice. In the wake of several federal circuit court
decisions interpreting the scope of federal jurisdiction under the Clean
Water Act (CWA),I any attorney wishing to give a client sound advice must
direct that client to seek the permission of the Army Corps of Engineers
(Corps) or the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), pursuant to 33
2
U.S.C. §§ 1311, 1342, 1344, prior to beginning a construction project in
many wetlands.
Construction in wetlands is exactly the situation which precipitated
the litigation in U.S. v. Bailey.3 In Bailey, the Eighth Circuit addressed the
issue of what legal test would be used to determine whether wetlands fall
under the jurisdiction of the CWA.4 In answering that question, the Eighth
Circuit expanded CWA jurisdiction over wetlands by deciding that
jurisdiction can be established if either of two tests proposed by the
plurality decision in the Supreme Court case of Rapanos v. U.S. are met.
In doing this, the Eighth Circuit has employed a Rapanos decision intended
to limit the scope of CWA jurisdiction to instead expand that jurisdiction.
This Comment will examine the Eighth Circuit's decision in U.S. v.
Bailey. First, an examination of the prior law will describe the statutes and
cases that led to the Eighth Circuit's decision. Second, the facts, reasoning,
and holding of Bailey will be explicated. Finally, the implications of Bailey
on CWA jurisdiction, the success of Justice Stevens' dissenting opinion in
* Technical Editor, KENTUCKY JOURNAL OF EQUINE, AGRICULTURE, AND NATURAL
RESOURCES LAW, 2010-2011. B.A. 2004 University of Louisville; J.D. expected May 2011, University
of Kentucky College of Law.
1 Federal Water Pollution Control Act Amendments of 1972, 33 U.S.C. §§ 1251 -1387
(2006).
2 33 U.S.C. §§ 1311, 1342, 1344 (2010) (establishing power to and procedure by which, the
Administrator of the EPA and the Secretary of the Army, acting through the Corps, issue permits for the
discharge of pollutants).
United States v. Bailey, 571 F.3d. 791, 795 (8th Cir. 2009).
4Id. at 796-799.
Rapanos v. United States, 547 U.S. 715 (2006).
6 Bailey, 571 F.3d at 799.