About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



49 Howard L.J. 31 (2005-2006)
Threats, Promises, and False Confessions: Lessons of Slavery

handle is hein.journals/howlj49 and id is 39 raw text is: Threats, Promises, and False Confessions:
Lessons of Slavery
ALAN HIRSCH*
Americans think of today's criminal justice system as more en-
lightened than those of earlier eras, and over time we have undeniably
increased protections afforded those suspected and accused of
crimes.1 Nevertheless, innocent persons are punished because we
have lost sight of truths keenly recognized in a relatively unenlight-
ened time and place: slave states in the antebellum south.
For more than a decade, pioneers in law and psychology have
warned that false confessions occur surprisingly often.2 With DNA
tests exonerating scores of persons wrongly accused and convicted of
crimes,3 claims of false confessions have been vindicated. Roughly
one-fourth of those exonerated had confessed.4 Based on statistics
and other data, there is reason to believe that false confessions occur
* Professor of Legal Studies, Williams College. J.D., Yale Law School, 1985. Special
thanks to Professors Saul Kassin and Steve Drizin, for their comments on an earlier draft and
their pioneering work in the field.
1. See Andrew Wright, Resisting Unlawful Arrests: Inviting Anarchy Or Protecting Individ-
ual Freedom? 46 DRAKE L. REV. 383, 392 (1997) (discussing this era of constantly expanding
legal protections of the rights of the accused).
2. See, e.g., SAUL KASSIN & LAWRENCE WRIGHTSMAN, CONFESSIONS IN THE COURTROOM
2-3 (1993).
3. See Barry Scheck & Peter Neufeld, DNA and Innocence Scholarship, in WRONGLY
CONVICTED 241 (Westervelt & Humphrey eds., 2001) (noting that, as of as of October 2000
there were eighty-two cases of post-conviction DNA exonerations. The number continues to
rise, and is now well over a hundred); Innocence Project.com, http://www.innocenceproject.com
(last visited July 7, 2005); The number of pre-conviction exonerations is a good deal higher still.
Steven Drizin & Richard Leo, The Problem of False Confessions In the Post-DNA World, 82
N.C. L. REV. 891, 900 (2004). Even when a false confession is rectified prior to conviction, it
remains a serious problem because virtually all false confessions result in some deprivation of
the false confessor's liberty and assorted other hardships, for example, harm to reputation,
income, and career. Id. at 949-50.
4. See JIM DWYER ET AL., ACTUAL INNOCENCE 92 (2000) (Among DNA exonerations
studied by the Innocence Project, 23 percent of the convictions were based on false confessions
or admissions.).
2005 Vol. 49 No. 1