About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



42 Env't F. 15 (2025)
Economic Significance of Power Sector Carbon Dioxide Emissions

handle is hein.journals/evnmtlfrum42 and id is 221 raw text is: 

                An Economic Perspective



Economic Significance of Power

Sector Carbon Dioxide Emissions


The Environmental Protection
      Agency   recently proposed
      repeal of the 2024 greenhouse
gas emissions standards for fossil fuel
electric-generating units. This regu-
lation establishes performance stan-
dards projected to reduce U.S. power
sector emissions of carbon dioxide by
approximately  1.4 billion tons over
the next  two decades. In  addition,
this rule  would  reduce  emissions
of fine particulate matter as well as
pollutants that contribute to higher
ground-level ozone.
   As a part of its justification for re-
pealing the power  plant  rule, EPA
claims that greenhouse gas emissions
from  the U.S. power  sector do not
contribute  significantly to danger-
ous air pollution. The EPA proposal
notes that the U.S. power sector share
of global emissions has
declined over time and      ,
represents only 3 per-
cent  of total annual        -:  -
global CO2  emissions.         .
The   proposal   con-
cludes that this sug-
gests that the risks to
public health and welfare attributed to
anthropogenic climate change would
not be meaningfully different even if
American  utilities totally eliminated
their greenhouse gas emissions.
   Annual U.S. power sector emissions
exceed the fossil fuel CO2 emissions of
every country in the world, except for
China, India, and Russia. If the rest of
the world took EPA's new  interpreta-
tion, then virtually every nation could
claim it does not  significandy con-
tribute to climate change and avoid
taking action. But the share-of-global-
emissions framing avoids entirely the
question of whether the public health
and welfare outcomes are significantly
affected by-or  meaningfully  differ-
ent under a reduction in-U.S. utility
emissions.
   Carbon dioxide from the U.S. pow-
er sector contributes to an array of ad-


  verse climate change impacts to public
  health and welfare, including increased
  premature  mortality, higher energy
  expenditures for cooling, reduced ag-
  ricultural output, greater infrastructure
  damages  from sea-level rise, and lower
  labor productivity. In 2023, EPA pro-
  duced  estimates of the social cost of
  carbon-the  loss in economic welfare
  associated with these impacts caused
  by  each ton of CO2  emissions. The
  agency's analysis drew from an exten-
  sive research literature published in
  top scientific and economic journals,
  building on guidance from a 2017 Na-
  tional Academy of Sciences report.
     Based on this work, EPA concluded
  in its regulatory analysis of the 2024
  rule that cutting power  plant CO2
  emissions would  produce about  $14
  billion in annual benefits from mitigat-
                 ing  climate change-
                 related  impacts  to
                 public   health  and
- -              welfare. This measure
                 represents the global
                 benefits of reducing
     ~  * U.S. power sector
                 emissions; a domestic-
  only measure would yield only about a
  billion dollars of benefits annually.
     Considering the longstanding regu-
  latory practice under Executive Order
  12866  and OMB Circular   A-4-dat-
  ing back to the Clinton administration
  and  used by the current administra-
  tion-to  deem  a regulatory action as
  economically  significant if it results
  in at least $100 million in annual im-
  pacts, the climate change benefits as-
  sociated with this rule easily meet this
  standard for significance.
     Applying a domestic-only measure
  of the adverse impacts to public health
  and welfare to annual U.S. power sector
  emissions results in annual damages on
  the order of nearly $25 billion. Claim-
  ing that 3 percent of a global problem is
  not significant, as well as claiming that
  addressing this share would not result
  in a meaningfully difference, is incom-


A'


plete and misleading. Three percent of
a trillion-dollar problem is significant.
   EPA's new proposal avoids such an
assessment by assuming zero benefits
from reducing CO2   pollution. Ignor-
ing both decades of research and regu-
latory agency practice in the Bush II,
Obama,  Trump   I, and Biden admin-
istrations, the current agency claims
that uncertainty  in estimating the
benefits of mitigating climate change
precludes any monetization. This ig-
nores both the approach under George
W. Bush, which focused on presenting
several estimates of the social cost of
carbon reflecting alternative scenarios,
and the more  recent work used in all
subsequent administrations, which fo-
cused on  probabilistic analysis of the
economic  and  scientific uncertainties
in estimating the impacts of climate
change. In short, regulators and schol-
ars have well-developed tools for incor-
porating uncertainty in their analysis of
climate change impacts.
   The  EPA   regulatory analysis for
its 2025 proposal does not produce a
monetized  measure of the impacts of
higher CO2,  fine particulate matter,
and other emissions. If the agency did
so, it would show that the regulatory
repeal delivers greater social costs (from
higher pollution) than social benefits
(from avoided regulatory compliance
costs). The climate change  impacts
from the U.S. power sector significant-
ly impact the public health and welfare
of Americans,  and rolling back this
regulation makes citizens significantly
worse off.


SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2025 | 15