About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



21 J. Legal Ethical & Regul. Isses 1 (2018)
Free-Riderism among Academicians: An Ethical of Islamic Perspective

handle is hein.journals/jnlolletl21 and id is 636 raw text is: 



Journal of Legal, Ethical and Regulatory Issues


      FREE-RIDERISM AMONG ACADEMICIANS: AN
             ETHICAL OF ISLAMIC PERSPECTIVE

                     Mohd   Nizam   Sahad,  Universiti  Sains  Malaysia
                        Fathullah  Asni,  Universiti Sains  Malaysia

                                     ABSTRACT

       Many  academics  emphasize free-riderism issues in academic writing. They give the
various factors of the problem, among which  are high KPI requirements and  compete for
promotion. This study is to identify non-ethical elements according to Islamic perspective in free-
riderism among academicians and therefore to provide solution methods to prevent free-riderism
practices. This study is qualitative in which data is collected through library research, i.e. by
referring to authoritative newspapers, Islamic ethics books, constitutions and journals. The data
were analyzed using document and content analysis. The findings show that there are three non-
ethical elements in free-riderism practices that include treason (khiyanah), fraud and trick
(hilah). The findings also show that there are ethical values of Islam to be applied in order to
prevent free-riderism practices among academics that include intent (niyyah), wasatiyyah, trust
(amanah) and courtesy (ihsan).

Keywords:  Islamic Ethics, Free-Riderism, Academicians, Malaysia, Legal.

                                   INTRODUCTION

       In line with the rising ranks of universities in Malaysia both at the local and international
levels is a remarkable achievement (Abdullah, 2018). This increase is because the policy of the
university is today which is fully autonomous, wants to meet the ranking criteria to compete with
universities at the international level. One of the criteria that need to be met is to multiply
indexed publishing quantities. The university has included these criteria as a compulsory
assignment of lecturers and compulsory requirements for graduates at post-graduate levels
(KPM,  2015). Although there is a positive impact on the policy, it is undeniable that there is a
negative impact. According to Yusof (2016), in an urgent situation to pursue ranks, names and
positions because of the urgent system pursuing  university ranking and achieving Key
Performance Index (KPI) respectively, through the volume and quantity of publications to be
published in the ISI, Scopus and ERA for an academic scholar within a year, has expressed
concern over the deteriorating moral and ethical values among university academic staff.
       Among  the moral values that concern is 'free-riderism practices among academics who
are so serious and uncontrolled has attracted some academics such as Salleh (2011), Yusof
(2016), Aminah  (2017), Khairunneezam (2017) and Kairuldin (2017). According to LaFollette
(1992), the term  'free-riderism comes from  terminology honorary  authorship or ghost
authorship. Honorary authorship is a practice of awarding to individuals in the form of writing


1544-0044-21-4-243


Volume 21, Issue 4, 2018


1