About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



22 Stan. L. & Pol'y Rev. 93 (2011)
Human Shields in Modern Armed Conflicts: The Need for a Proportionate Proportionality

handle is hein.journals/stanlp22 and id is 95 raw text is: HUMAN SHIELDS IN MODERN ARMED
CONFLICTS: THE NEED FOR A
PROPORTIONATE PROPORTIONALITY
Amnon Rubinstein,* Yaniv Roznai**
It would not be right ... that the Aggressor Power should gain one set of advantages by
tearing up all laws, and another set by sheltering behind the innate respect for law of its
opponents. Humanity, rather than legality, must be our guide.
-Winston S. Churchill
INTRODUCTION
The use of civilians as human shields during hostilities has become one of
the major problems facing democracies in contemporary armed conflicts. As
the modem battlefield has moved from the front, where armies clash, to
populated urban environments in which civilians' involvement in hostilities has
been dramatically augmented, so, too, the use of human shields has
dramatically escalated. Indeed, the use of civilians as human shields during
armed conflicts has become an important weapon in waging a new type of
warfare that relies on the belligerent's observance of international law.
This Article asserts that, despite their growing importance, these
occurrences are not given the attention they deserve from the international
community. Moreover, in our view, the existing application-by some
international community members-of the laws of war regarding the use of
civilians as human shields in armed conflicts leads to absurd and harmful
results, with major theoretical and practical implications for Western and
American defense policy makers.
Part I of the Article reviews the issue of human shields in modern armed
conflicts. Part II reviews the international laws of armed conflict governing the
* Law Professor, Interdisciplinary Center (IDC), Herzliya, Israel; an Israel Prize laureate.
** PhD Candidate, the London School of Economics and Political Science (LSE), UK. The
authors would like to thank Liav Orgad, Tal Becker, and the participants of the Stanford
Defense Policy Symposium for their invaluable comments on an earlier draft of this piece,
and to Stefanie Raker and Carine Rozen for assistance with editing. The authors would also
like to express their appreciation to the staff of the Stanford Law and Policy Review,
especially Gabe Ledeen, Ashley Romero, Noah Smith-Drelich, and Elizabeth Balassone for
their insightful editing and earnest diligence.

93