About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



37 Law & Psychol. Rev. 119 (2013)
Can the Courts Tell an Ear from an Eye: Legal Approaches to Voice Identification Evidence

handle is hein.journals/lpsyr37 and id is 127 raw text is: CAN THE COURTS TELL AN EAR FROM AN EYE? LEGAL
APPROACHES TO VOICE IDENTIFICATION EVIDENCE
Cindy E. Laub, Lindsey E. Wylie, and Brian H. Bornstein *
ABSTRACT
We conducted an empirical legal analysis concerning cases that
involved voice identification (earwitness testimony) as evidence. The courts
allowed the testimony anytime the identification was not suggestive. When
the identification was obtained under circumstances that have been found
to reduce the reliability of the identification, the courts often conducted an
analysis to guarantee that the identification was reliable. In only a handful
of cases did the court disallow a voice identification, even under
questionable situations. Rarely have the courts allowed expert testimony
concerning the fallibility of voice recognition evidence or presented special
jury instructions. These findings have important implications for persons
identified by an earwitness.
The legal system relies heavily on witness identifications for
investigating and prosecuting crimes.' The role of witness identification
can be extremely important, especially when there is no additional physical
evidence.2 Nonetheless, identification errors are the leading cause offalse
convictions.3 Psychology has built a great deal of scientific literature on
eyewitness identification and has aptly advised the justice system of
problems associated with eyewitness identification.4
* Cindy E. Laub is a criminology analyst for the City and County of Denver, Colorado and
adjunct professor of psychology at Metropolitan State College of Denver. Lindsey E. Wylie
is a law student and psychology graduate student at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln.
Brian H. Bornstein is professor of psychology and courtesy professor of law at the
University of Nebraska-Lincoln.
1. Gary L. Wells & Elizabeth A. Olson, Eyewitness Testimony, 54 ANN. REV. PSYcHOL.
277, 277 (2003).
2. See id. at 278.
3. Gary L. Wells & Deah S. Quinlivan, Suggestive Eyewitness Identiication
Procedures and the Supreme Court's Reliability Test in Light of Eyewitness Science: 30
Years Later, 33 LAW & HUM. BEHAV. 1, 2 (2009).
4. See State v. Henderson, 27 A.3d 872, 877-880 (N.J. 2011).