About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



37 Calif. L. Rev. 1 (1949)
Issue 1

handle is hein.journals/calr37 and id is 17 raw text is: California Law Review
VOL. XXXVII              MARCH, 1949                       No. 1
Long-Term Options
and the Rule Against Perpetuities
William Berg, Jr.*
INTRODUCTION
So ME thirty-three years ago a law review commentator admonished
his readers in this ominous fashion: Before we pull the heavens
down, let us sit and think a little.' This warning was issued at the
conclusion of a brief note dealing with the applicability of the Rule
against Perpetuities to unlimited'2 options to purchase property.
Since then the courts3 and legal scholars4 have devoted more than a
little thinking to this particular subject, but it is debatable whether
their efforts have led to a clear solution of this most vexatious problem.
It would be presumptuous for the author to suggest that he has
discovered an analysis that will put the problem to rest. Such an
achievement probably cannot be claimed until the meaning of the
Rule against Perpetuities has been freed of the fog of obscurity which
now surrounds it. But a brief study of the background of the per-
petuities subject and of its principal present-day versions, in con-
junction with a study of the structure and purposes of the long-term
land-purchase option, may in an appreciable manner serve to chart a
course for future handling of the problem. Such a study should dispel
some of the confusion that permeates the cases wherein the problem
has been considered in the past.
It is difficult to share what seems to have been the optimism of a
Maryland Court of Appeals judge who once said, The rule against
* Professor of Law, University of Colorado.
1Note (1916) 14 Micn. L. REv. 231 at 233.
2 Two options were under discussion. The first was a reserved perpetual option in
gross, and the second a reserved 99 year option in gross. Both were held void in Woodall
v. Bruen (1915) 76 W.Va. 193, 85 S. E. 170.
3The cases will be listed in a later installment of this paper.