About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



66 Tex. L. Rev. 1561 (1987-1988)
Academic Freedom and Governance: A Call for Increased Dialogue and Diversity

handle is hein.journals/tlr66 and id is 1595 raw text is: Academic Freedom and Governance: A Call
for Increased Dialogue and Diversity
Phoebe A. Haddon*
I welcome the opportunity to participate in this Symposium, partic-
ularly at a time when I have taken a leave of absence from law school
teaching to think about recent events at my law school and others that
bear upon the meaning of academic freedom and governance. I would
like to comment on several of these events, including the issues concern-
ing diversity and community that they raise and how they affect my un-
derstanding of the academic freedom and governance concepts that we
are struggling to define.
During the 1986-1987 school year, the president of Temple Univer-
sity summarily dismissed the law school dean, a black man. While mem-
bers of the law school faculty were en route to an Association of
American Law Schools (AALS) conference in Los Angeles or otherwise
engaged in semester break activities, the university president locked the
dean out of his office and appointed a new acting dean.' Although the
president telephoned some members of the law school faculty on the
night of the lockout, he consulted neither the faculty as a whole nor a
faculty liaison committee that had been meeting throughout the fall with
* Associate Professor of Law, Temple University (currently on leave). B.A. 1972, Smith Col-
lege; J.D. 1977, Duquesne University; LL.M. 1985, Yale University.
1. Accounts conflict on the events triggering the dean's termination and lockout. The univer-
sity president announced early in the fall of 1986 that he would remove the law school dean at the
end of the school year. The law school faculty liaison committee, elected by a faculty majority, met
during the fall with the university administration to resolve the resulting dispute over the faculty's
role in termination decisions. To buttress the faculty position, the committee requested relief on
December 31, 1986, from the Association of American Law Schools (AALS) and the American Bar
Association (ABA) Accreditation Committee of the Section of Legal Education and Admissions to
the Bar. The liaison committee contended that the university president's unilateral action implicated
ABA and AALS governing provisions, including ABA standards 204,205,211, and 405, AMERICAN
BAR ASS'N, APPROVAL OF LAW SCHOOLS: STANDARDS AND RULES OF PROCEDURE 3, 5, 12
(amended 1983), and AALS article 6-6 on law school governance, ASSOCIATION OF AM. LAW
SCHOOLS, ASSOCIATION HANDBOOK, Apr. 1986, at 24. The ABA committee sent a visiting panel to
interview faculty, students, and university and law school administrators. Members of the faculty
and the liaison committee submitted contradictory versions of the events to the visiting panel. Each
of these versions are a part of the investigation record and are on file in the dean's office of the
Temple University School of Law and the Office of the Consultant on Legal Education to the ABA.
My purpose is not to focus on the events leading to the lockout, but to consider the effects of the
termination and lockout on the faculty's ability to play its appropriate role in the academic enter-
prise. Despite the faculty's good faith efforts to clarify its governance role through discussion, the
physical act of locking out the dean and the unilateral appointment of an acting dean were suppres-
sive, casting doubt on the value of dialogue and reducing the process to a meaningless charade.

1561