About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



40 U. Haw. L. Rev. 141 (2017-2018)
How Much Is Police Brutality Costing America

handle is hein.journals/uhawlr40 and id is 149 raw text is: 







       How Much is Police Brutality Costing

                              America?



                              Eleanor Lumsden*


INTRODUCTION............................................142
I.    A BRIEF  HISTORY   OF  POLICING..........................145
II.   FEDERAL LAW .....................               ...................155
     A.   The United States Constitution...........................155
     B.  Federal Statutory Law .........................          .............158
III.  THE  COMMON LAW OF TORTS......................162
IV.   THE  COSTS  OF  POLICE  BRUTALITY.......................165
     A.  Direct, Current Costs..................         ................165
         1.  Costs to Victims ..................        .................165
         2.  Broken Homes  and Families..........................172
     B.  Indirect, Current Costs.................................174
         1.  Costs to States and Local Governments..............174
         2.  Costs to Communities...............................177
     C.  Indirect, Future Costs...................................181
         1.  Distrust ofLaw Enforcement..........................181
         2.  Lack of Trust in the Social Compact...........          ..........183
         3.  The Cost to Law and Order...........................184
         4.  The Cost to our Reputation...........................188
         5.  Black Flight....................          ..................190
V.   LEGAL   &  POLICY  RECOMMENDATIONS               ...................193
VI.  CONCLUSION......................................... 201









.Associate Professor, Golden Gate University School of Law, J.D., NYU School of Law,
A.B., Princeton University. A draft of this Article was first presented at the Lutie Lytle
Black Women's Conference held at Iowa School of Law in July 2016, and I am grateful for
the advice and suggestions given to me by participants of that conference. I would especially
like to thank my research assistants, Khaleelah Ahmad and Katie Wilde for their invaluable
contributions. I would also like to thank Judge Victor Hwang, Norm Stamper, and my
colleagues at GGU School of Law and throughout the academy that offered written
comments  and feedback, including but not limited to, Professors Leslie Burton, Eric
Christiansen, Helen Kang, Paul Kibel, Russell Robinson, Leslie Rose, and Mark Yates.
Special thanks also to Ramey Barnett, and to GGU Law for the scholarship assistance
needed to complete this project.