About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



62 S. Tex. L. Rev. 13 (2022-2023)
The Future of the Freedom of Religion on State No-Aid Provisions: The Effect of Espinoza v. Montana Department of Revenue

handle is hein.journals/stexlr62 and id is 25 raw text is: 









   THE FUTURE OF THE FREEDOM OF RELIGION ON

      STATE NO-AID PROVISIONS: THE EFFECT OF

  ESPINOZA V. MONTANA DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE


                          ETHAN   SZUMANSKIt

I. INTRODUCTION   ........................................................................................ 14
II. B ACKGROUND   .....................................................................................  15
        A.  The Backdrop  to Blaine: The Origin and History of State Blaine
            A m endm ents ..........................................................................  15
        B.  The Relevant History of the Religion Clauses ...................... 19
              1.  The Free Exercise Clause........................................... 19
              2.  The Establishment Clause........................................... 24
III. THE BATTLE  OF THE BLAINE  AMENDMENTS: LOCKE AND THE OPEN
       D O O R .............................................................................................  27
IV. THE BACKGROUND OF ESPINOZA V. MONTANA DEPARTMENT OF
       R EVEN U E ........................................................................................ 30
       A.   Factual and Procedural  Background  .................................. 30
       B.   The M ajority Opinion ..........................................................  31
V. THE  ANNULMENT OF NO-AID PROVISIONS THROUGH ESPINOZA .......... 32
        A.  Status-Based Neutrality in No-Aid Provisions...................... 32
        B.  Irrelevance of the Restrictiveness of No-Aid Provisions ......... 34
VI. THE FREE  EXERCISE  CLAUSE  AND  CONDUCT-BASED DISCRIMINATION
       THROUGH   NO-AID  PROVISIONS   .................................................. 35
VII. CONCLUSION........................................................................................ 38





    t   Ethan Szumanski is a licensed attorney in the State of Texas. In December 2021, he
graduated summa cum laude from South Texas College of Law. Graduating at the age of nineteen,
he was the youngest person to ever graduate from South Texas College of Law. Nonetheless, he
could not have accomplished anything without the sacrifice and investment of several very special
people. Specifically, he would like to thank Professor Josh Blackman for his authentic and insightful
feedback on this article and his treasured and continued mentorship. In addition, he would like to
thank the editorial staff of South Texas Law Review for their helpful suggestions, as well as
Professor Maxine Goodman and Professor Rob Galloway for making him a better writer and
advocate. Finally, and most importantly, he would like to thank his family for their unwavering
support and encouragement, and he would specifically like to honor his wonderful and sacrificing
mother, Mindi Szumanski, for igniting a passion for the written word and for instilling in him the
courage, grit, and gusto to make a difference wherever possible.


13