About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



30 Stan. L. & Pol'y Rev. 61 (2019)
Am I an Algorithm or a Product: When Products Liability Should Apply to Algorithmic Decision-Makers

handle is hein.journals/stanlp30 and id is 69 raw text is: 












    AM I AN ALGORITHM OR A PRODUCT?

    WHEN PRODUCTS LIABILITY SHOULD

              APPLY TO ALGORITHMIC

                  DECISION-MAKERS


                  Kami   A. Chagal-Feferkom*



INTRODUCTION............................................................62
PART I: WHY NOT USE AUTONOMY TO DISTINGUISH PRODUCTS FROM
   THINKICNG ALGORITHMS?         ........................................ ........70
   A. On Automation and Autonomy         ............................ ......70
   B. The Many Faces of Autonomy                ...................................72
PART II: PRODUCTS LIABILITY RATIONALES         ................  ..................77
PART III: IS IT A PRODUCT? IS THERE A DEFECT?   ..................... .....82
   A. On Products          ................................................83
   B. On Defects                       .................................................84
PART IV: DISTINGUISHING PRODUCTS FROM THINKING ALGORITHMS ....................87
   A. Examples of Products Versus Thinking Algorithms .......     ............88
   B. Which Products Liability Rationales Apply to Which Algorithms .......90
       1. Promoting Safety..........................................90
         a. The OODA  Loop-General        ............  ...................94
         b. Observe (Information Acquisition) ......................95
         c. Orient (Information Analysis)  .................... .....97
         d. Decide (Decision Selection) ...........................99
         e. Act (Action Implementation) ........................ ...........101
         f. Interim Summary and Measurability of Success Rates .................101
      2. Avoiding a Chilling Effect................................102
      3. Victims' Compensation   ........................................104
   C. Keep It Simple, System.......................................107
CONCLUSIONS....................           .......................... ......113




      * Fellow, Haifa Center for Law & Technology, University of Haifa Faculty of Law.
I thank Niva Elkin-Koren for her endless support that made this research possible. I would
also like to thank Yonatan Arbel, Michal Gal, Yaron David, Itiel Dror, Orr Dunkelman, Rita
Osadchy, Amnon Reichman, Catherine Sharkey, and Avinoam Zimerman. This research was
supported by the Center for Cyber Law & Policy (CCLP), established by the University of
Haifa in collaboration with the Israeli National Cyber Bureau. Any mistakes or omissions are
the author's.


61