About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



22 N.Y.U. J. Legis. & Pub. Pol'y 197 (2019-2020)
The Meaning of Leave: Understanding Workplace Leave Rights

handle is hein.journals/nyulpp22 and id is 197 raw text is: 












            THE MEANING OF LEAVE:

        UNDERSTANDING WORKPLACE

                      LEAVE RIGHTS

                      Molly Weston Williamson*

        While much work remains to be done, the United States is experiencing
    a period of rapid and unprecedented progress in expanding workplace leave
    rights, particularly at the state level. Yet our policy vocabulary has not kept
    pace. What we refer to as leave rights are actually at least six kinds of
    rights, which appear in different combinations across many types of laws.
    This Article identifies the six distinct leave rights and analyzes various kinds
    of existing leave laws under the six-right framework, in order to better un-
    derstand the existing policy landscape and provide more nuanced tools for
    future policymaking.

INTRODUCTION   .............................................     198              R
    I.  THE  UNIVERSE:  LEAVE  LAWS   ........................   199              R
    II. THE  SIX LEAVE  RIGHTS  ............................. 203                 R
        A.  The  Right to Leave  ...........................   204              R
        B.  The  Right to Reinstatement ......................   209              R
            1.  What  Qualifies as Reinstatement? ............   214              R
            2.  Variations on the Right to Reinstatement  ..... .219              R
            3.  Determining  the Scope  of the Right to
                Reinstatement  ..............................    220              R
        C.  The  Right to Pay ............................... 224                 R
        D.  The  Right to Continuation of Health Insurance  ...  233              R
        E.  The  Right Not to Be Retaliated Against ..........   238              R
            1.  The  Scope  of the Right Against Retaliation:
                Identifying the Protected Action(s) ...........  241              R
            2.  Theory  and Practice: Interpreting the Scope of
                the Protection ...............................   244              R
            3.  Proving  Retaliation ........................ 247                 R
        F.  The  Right Not to Be Interfered With .............   249              R
   III. USING  THE LEAVE   RIGHTS  FRAMEWORK TO EVALUATE
        LAW  AND  POLICY  .....................................  252              R


   * Margaret (Molly) Weston Williamson is Director of Paid Leave and Future of
Work and Senior Staff Attorney at A Better Balance. All opinions are the author's
own. Special thanks to Lynn Conell-Price, Alexandra List, and James Williamson for
their support and assistance.

                                 197


Imaged with Permission of N.Y.U. Journal of Legislation and Public Policy