About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



35 J. Am. Acad. Matrimonial Law. 1 (2022-2023)
Equality, Gestational Erasure, and the Constitutional Law of Parenthood

handle is hein.journals/jaaml35 and id is 15 raw text is: 










Gestational  Erasure


Equality, Gestational Erasure, and the

Constitutional Law of Parenthood



by
Katharine   K. Baker*


Abstract

        This article calls into question the abundance of academic writing
    that criticizes, as inconsistent with equality principles, the constitu-
    tional law of parenthood. Some of this criticism, concerned with gen-
    der  stereotypes, argues that the current doctrine's preferential
    treatment of gestational mothers inexcusably discriminates against fa-
    thers. Other critics focus on how the Supreme Court's approach to
    gestational investment excludes same sex partners from parental
    rights. Both of these critiques argue that the work of gestation has
    been overvalued. They both endorse a kind of gestational erasure, but
    they differ sharply on where they root the essence of parenthood.
    Those concerned about equal treatment for fathers root parenthood in
    genetics. Those concerned about equal treatment for same sex part-
    ners root parenthood in parental investment. This article highlights
    the tension between these positions and challenges those willing to
    erase the relevance of gestation at both a normative and practical
    level. It explains how discounting the relevance of gestation will have
    serious consequences for the law of abortion, adoption, and custody,
    placing already vulnerable women at more risk of being controlled by
    men  they want to escape. Further, this article argues that the current
    constitutional doctrine, which recognizes the salience of gestation,
    necessarily incorporates what LGBTQ advocates argue must be incor-
    porated into decisions about parenthood: parental investment. What
    is inconsistent with LGBTQ equality in parenthood is not a regime
    that recognizes gestational investment, but one that reifies the genetic
    essentialism on which the gender-stereotype critique relies.


INTRODUCTION

     In the last ten years there has been  a flurry of academic  writ-
ing criticizing the constitutional law of parenthood.   This  scholar-


     * University Distinguished Professor of Law, IIT Chicago-Kent College
of Law. Thanks to Michelle Oberman and all of my colleagues who have made
comments  over the years on the arguments I've finally brought together in this
piece.


Vol. 35, 2022


1