About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



75 Tex. L. Rev. 1605 (1996-1997)
Negligence= Economic Efficiency: Doubts >

handle is hein.journals/tlr75 and id is 1621 raw text is: Negligence = Economic Efficiency: Doubts >
Michael D. Green*
I.   Introduction
It has been half a century since Judge Learned Hand provided, in
United States v. Carroll Towing Co.,' his algebraic formulation for
negligence: PL > B.2 When I first began teaching Torts, I had under-
stood Carroll Towing as a seminal case-one that provided the seeds for an
economic test for negligence, an alternative to the general reasonable per-
son standard so prevalent then (and still today).3 Thus, Carroll Towing
was an early forerunner of the law and economics movement. With their
eye on economic efficiency, these law and economics adherents claimed (in
the normative version) that either the law should pursue efficiency as its
goal or (in its positive or descriptive version) that the law is constructed so
as to pursue efficiency as its norm.4
There can be little doubt that the Carroll Towing formula has influ-
enced tort law throughout the past fifty years. The Restatement (Second)
of Torts, published some eighteen years later, reflects the Carroll Towing
standard, providing a risk-benefit test for unreasonable conduct and
* Professor of Law, University of Iowa College of Law. I would like to thank the participants
of the W. Page Keeton Symposium on Tort Law at the University of Texas School of Law and a fac-
ulty workshop at the Case Western Reserve University Law School, at which earlier versions of this
Paper were discussed. Stephen Gilles, Ken Kress, David Owen, Gary Schwartz, Bob Strassfeld,
Randall Thomas, Michael Wells, and Jerry Wetlaufer provided helpful comments on an earlier draft
of this Paper. I would also like to express my admiration of and appreciation for Page Keeton, who
has, over many decades, contributed so magnificently to a better understanding of tort law. Tracy
Edgerton has provided indispensable research assistance with grace and good humor.
1. 159 F.2d 169 (2d Cir. 1947). Hand had provided a nonalgebraic, descriptive version of this
risk-benefit test in two earlier cases. See Conway v. O'Brien, 111 F.2d 611, 612 (2d Cir. 1940);
Gunnarsonv. Robert Jacob, Inc., 94 F.2d 170, 172 (2d Cir. 1938) (both asserting that the degree of
care required is found by balancing three factors: likelihood of injury, seriousness of injury, and cost
of avoiding the risk).
2. Carroll Towing, 159 F.2d at 173.
3. The question of whether the risk-benefit version of negligence provided by Judge Hand is
simply a more specific version of the reasonable person test is a matter addressed infra text
accompanying notes 116-21.
4. See generally WILLIAM M. LANDES & RICHARD A. POSNER, THE ECONOMIC STRUCTURE OF
TORT LAw (1987).