About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



11 Cardozo L. Rev. 1355 (1989-1990)
Talking about Difference: Meanings and Metaphors of Individuality

handle is hein.journals/cdozo11 and id is 1369 raw text is: TALKING ABOUT DIFFERENCE- MEANINGS
AND METAPHORS OF INDIVIDUALITY
Gregory S. Alexander*
This paper discusses the relationship between communitarianism
and difference theory. Specifically, it focuses on the rhetorical prac-
tices that have created an apparent conflict between difference theory
and communitarianism. My purpose is to suggest why this conflict
dissolves when community and difference are understood-as strategic
rhetorics that share a common political vision.
Difference theory, which has come on the scene in the-past few
years, expresses the political vision of ending the oppression of mem-
bers of dominated social groups. It expresses this vision through a
rhetoric that emphasizes what separates those individuals from others
in society. Difference theorists assert a positivity and pride in group
specificity against ideals of assimilation.' They further argue that a
differentiated rather than an assimilated conception of citizen-
ship is the best means to realize the ideals of inclusion- and
participation.2
It is easy to understand why difference critics have-been uneasy
about the rhetoric of community in recent political writing. Commu-
nity is a term that encompasses quite different concepts.3 Modem
communitarians generally use the term to emphasize notions of soli-
darity, integration, and the common good as well as. traditional
Gemeinschaft values of intimacy and rootedness.4 This version of
communitarianism objects to liberal political theorists' rhetoric of vol-
untary choice at the expense of a substantive moral rhetoric.5 Mod-
* Professor of Law, Cornell University. I am grateful to Kathryn Abrams, C. Edwin
Baker, Katherine Van Wezel Stone, and Steven Winter for their comments on an earlier draft
of this paper.
I Young, Polity and Group Difference: A Critique of the Ideal of Universal Citizenship,
99 Ethics 250, 251 (1989).
2 For especially explicit statements of this view, see Young, supra note 1; Young, The
Ideal of Community and the Politics of Difference, 12 Soc. Theory & Practice 1 (1986). On
the sameness/difference debate within American feminism, see Scott, Gender and the Politics
of History 167-77 (1988); Cornell, The Doubly-Prized World: Myth, Allegory, and the Femi-
nine, 75 Cornell L. Rev. (forthcoming 1990); Williams, Deconstructing Gender, 87 Mich. L.
Rev. 797 (1989); West, Jurisprudence and Gender, 55 U. Chi. L. Rev. 1 (1988);. Littleton,
Reconstructing Sexual Equality, 75 Calif. L. Rev. 1279 (1987).
3 See Dworkin, Liberal Community, 77-Calif. L. Rev. 479 (1989) (distinguishing and criti-
quing four, different normative meanings of community).
4 See, e.g., R. Unger, Knowledge and Politics (1975).
5- See, e.g., C. Taylor, Sources of the Self passim (1989); Philosophical Papers, vol. 2:

1355