About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



22 Int'l Crim. L. Rev. 1168 (2022)
Treaty-Based Regulation and Evidence-Extradition Agreements as Critical Tools in the Fight against International Criminal Wrongdoing

handle is hein.journals/intcrimlrb22 and id is 1171 raw text is: INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL LAW REVIEW
Criminal Law
BRILL                     22 (2022) 1168-1187                  Reew
N IJ H O F F                                                     brill.com/icla
Treaty-Based Regulation and Evidence-Extradition
Agreements as Critical Tools in the Fight against
International Criminal Wrongdoing
Courtney Martin O RC 1D: 0000-0002-8492-8572
Department of Law, National University of Ireland Galway,
University Road, Galway, Ireland
c.martin22@nuigaiway.ie
Abstract
Draft Article 7 of the UN Draft Convention regarding Crimes Against Humanity
provides the terra firma for States to establish and exercise a range of jurisdictional
bases, including universal jurisdiction, to be reinforced by State-to-State agreements
regarding evidence-extradition for the benefit of downstream truth and justice seeking
projects. Legal analysis demonstrates there persists an insistence on treaty regulation
and clearly particularised laws at local and international levels to successfully pursue
international criminal accountability. Draft Article 7 will give credence to universal
jurisdiction, complement the International Criminal Court's workings and counter
its temporal limitations, and negate politically-motivated invocation of the doctrine.
A case study involving Australian extradition proceedings highlights how evidence
can be obtained efficiently on the basis of a pre-existing bilateral agreement between
culturally distinct States. Formal arrangements regarding evidence-exchange will
espouse a greater willingness by States to cooperate across borders and will strengthen
universality by taking some of the guess-work out of its exercise.
Keywords
universal jurisdiction - Draft Convention Crimes Against Humanity - extradition

© KONINKLIJKE BRILL NV, LEIDEN, 2021  DOI:10.1163/15718123-BJA10085