About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



25 Nat. Resources & Env't 12 (2010-2011)
Green Energy Tax Policies: State and Federal Tax Incentives for Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency

handle is hein.journals/nre25 and id is 218 raw text is: Green Energy Tax Policies: State and
Federal Tax Incentives for Renewable
Energy and Energy Efficiency

Jerome L. Garciano

mong the various federal and state policies addressing
climate change and energy independence are the of-
ten overlooked tax incentives and policies relating to
renewable energy and energy efficiency. While not as
prominently discussed in policy circles as cap and trade, carbon tax,
or cash grant programs, tax incentives can play an important role
in achieving the twin goals of increasing clean energy production
and decreasing energy used, which will move our country toward
a more sustainable energy platform. Numerous federal tax incen-
tives in the Internal Revenue Code (IRC) are designed to promote
clean energy production and energy conservation. Incentives for
renewable energy production, manufacturing, and investment, such
as the IRC § 48 Investment Tax Credit, are some of the tax ben-
efits designed to spur on the sustainability movement. A number of
tax-exempt bonds are also available for energy projects for qualify-
ing energy conservation and renewable energy projects. Incentives
for energy efficiency include the IRC § 179D Energy Efficient
Commercial Building Tax Deduction and the IRC § 25D income
tax credit for residential energy efficient property. These federal tax
benefits provide an important source of financial incentives to the
private sector to motivate market shifts on both energy fronts.
State tax incentives also play an important role in shaping energy
policy at the local level. While these incentives typically involve
smaller dollar amounts, they are often tailored to regional economic
conditions and policy goals that promote green job creation. State
tax incentives also take on several different forms reflecting the
numerous taxation schemes at the state level, which, in addition to
income taxes, include sales, property, and business taxes.
This article takes a broad look at the tax incentives for renew-
able energy and energy efficiency at the federal and state levels.
This article also surveys state programs and analyzes popular
policy objectives and trends. Current and future challenges to
the efficacy of these tax incentives are described, as well as some
suggested general policy changes. In examining these subjects, it
is important to emphasize the lack of consensus on the meaning
of the term renewable energy. For example, under IRC § 45, the
federal tax credit for renewable electricity production, renewable
energy is defined as wind, closed-loop biomass, open-loop biomass,
geothermal energy, solar energy, small irrigation power, municipal
solid waste, hydropower, marine, and hydrokinetic renewables. By
Mr. Garciano is a tax attorney and member of the Energy Group at
Edwards Angell Palmer & Dodge LLP in Boston. He is a LEED AP and
may be reached atjgarciano@eapdlaw.com.

comparison, New Mexico has defined qualifying activities in simi-
lar incentives for advanced energy to include solar thermal, solar
photovoltaic, geothermal, recycled energy, repowered coal-based
electricity, and coal gasification energy. N.M. STAT. ANN. § 7-2A-
25. In addition, various renewable technologies may be known by
different names and have significant overlap. In this regard, many
states categorize nuclear power, carbon sequestration, and clean
coal as both renewable and clean technologies. And not surprising-
ly, some states avoid the problem by not defining the concept at all.
For the purpose of this article, the current definition at Wikipedia
serves as good a benchmark as any: Renewable energy is energy
which comes from natural resources such as sunlight, wind, rain,
tides, and geothermal heat, which are ... naturally replenished.
Policy Initiatives Quaibing for the Incentives
The first main policy initiative is the support of energy pro-
duction from renewable sources. Considering federal and state
programs together, the following energy sources or technologies
fall within the definition of renewable energy: wind, solar electric,
solar thermal, geothermal, hydroelectric, methane, biomass,
alternative fuel, biodiesel, biofuel, ethanol, electric vehicle, fuel
cell, cogeneration, irrigation, and marine.
At the federal level, the IRC § 45 tax credit for renewable
electricity production and IRC § 48 tax credit for investments in
energy property have been the main programs leading the way in
this arena for many years. IRC § 45 provides an income tax credit
in the amount of $0.021 (in 2009) per kilowatt hour of electricity
produced from qualifying renewable resources during a ten-year
period. The taxpayer must produce electricity from qualifying re-
newable resources and sell the electricity produced to an unrelated
person. IRC § 48 provides an income tax credit in the amount of
10 percent or 30 percent with the basis of qualifying energy prop-
erty investments in fuel cell property, solar energy property, small
wind energy property, geothermal property, geothermal heat pump
systems property, microturbine property, and combined heat and
power system property. Also prominent at the federal level are the
numerous tax incentives for alternative fuels and motor vehicles.
Income tax credits for bondholders of clean renewable energy
bonds (CREBs) have also become increasingly popular. CREBs are
registered bonds issued by a qualifying issuer under the national
clean renewable energy bond limitation; 95 percent or more of the
proceeds of the issue are used for capital expenditures incurred by
a government body or a mutual or cooperative electric company

NR&E Spring 2011

12