About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



23 Cardozo L. Rev. 1281 (2001-2002)
The Right Questions about School Choice: Education, Religious Freedom, and the Common Good

handle is hein.journals/cdozo23 and id is 1303 raw text is: THE RIGHT QUESTIONS ABOUT SCHOOL
CHOICE: EDUCATION, RELIGIOUS
FREEDOM, AND THE COMMON GOOD
Richard W. Garnett*
As this Essay goes to press, the Supreme Court is considering
whether     Ohio's    school-choice     program      violates   the    First
Amendment to the United States Constitution.' In my view, the
Ohio program is sound public policy, and it is consistent with the
Justices' present understanding of the Establishment Clause.' I
also believe that the Court will and should permit this experiment,
and our conversations about its merits, to continue.' The purpose
of this Essay, though, is not to predict or evaluate ex ante the
Court's decision. Instead, my primary aim is to suggest and then
* I thank Michael Barkey, A.J. Bellia, Nicole Stelle Garnett, Diane Meyers, John
Copeland Nagle, John Robinson, Robert Vischer, and Eugene Volokh for their comments
and assistance. Thanks are due also to Jeremy Samson and to the staff of the Cardozo
Law Review for their help and patience. Parts of this Essay grew out of a talk given at the
St. John's University School of Law in November of 2000. I should also note that I have
elsewhere asked, and tried to answer, many of the questions raised here. See, e.g., Richard
W. Garnett, The Story of Henry Adams's Soul: Education and the Expression of
Associations, 85 MINN. L. REV. 1841 (2001); Richard W. Garnett, Brown's Promise,
Blaine's Legacy, 17 CONST. COMM. 651 (2000) (reviewing JOSEPH P. VITERIT-I,
CHOOSING EQUALITY: SCHOOL CHOICE, THE CONSTITUTION, AND CIVIL SOCIETY
(1999)); Richard W. Garnett, Taking Pierce Seriously: The Family, Religious Education,
and Harm to Children, 76 NOTRE DAME L. REV. 109 (2000); Nicole Stelle Garnett &
Richard W. Garnett, School Choice, the First Amendment, and Social Justice, 4 TEX. REV.
L. & POL. 301 (2000).
' In late 2000, the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit affirmed a
lower-court ruling striking down Cleveland's school-choice program on First Amendment
grounds. See Simmons-Harris v. Zelman, 234 F.3d 945, 961 (6th Cir. 2000). As expected,
the United States Supreme Court agreed to review that decision. Zelman v. Simmons-
Harris, 533 U.S. 983 (2001); see Charles Lane, Supreme Court: On the Sidelines, for Now,
WASH. POST, Sept. 30, 2001, at A5 (If the court upholds the Cleveland plan, it could
reenergize a pro-voucher movement that stalled in recent years[.]).
2 For a very different view, see, e.g., Editorial, A Matter of Church and State, N.Y.
TIMES, Feb. 20,2002, at A20 (Even if the voucher program were not unconstitutional,....
we would object to it because it drains human and financial resources from public
education without solving the real problems facing American education.).
3 Cf Washington v. Glucksberg, 531 U.S. 702, 735 (1997) (Throughout the Nation,
Americans are engaged in an earnest and profound debate about the morality, legality,
and practicality of physician-assisted suicide. Our holding permits this debate to continue,
as it should in a democratic society.).

1281