About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



34 J. Pat. Off. Soc'y 106 (1952)
The Early Growth and Influence of Intellectual Property

handle is hein.journals/jpatos34 and id is 132 raw text is: • I,:',)/ l of the Paten  Oihu: 86ociclY

The Early Growth and Influence of
Intellectual Property
B   F. 1). PRAGI-li
it is usually assumed that the modern system     of pat-
cats and copy'rights was de-eloped from so-called mnedie-
val privileges, by the exercise of' royal, economic stales-
manship. The present essay proposes to show that this
accepted viewv is inconplele, and that the system  has a
second historic root hi t he ancient and eternal idea of
iiitellecltua lroperly.
Piwviot. LITERATURE
It is generally assumned that English royalty was lead-
ing in the process of evolving modern patents. For a long
time it wa-s thought that English rulers somehow dev-el-
oped the individual patent monopoly from earlier eollec-
tire monopolies of gilds and trading companies.'      The
now accepLed story is different and more detailed, but is
still based on the assumption that the entire process was
guided decisively by acts of Engli-sh councillors and
judges.2  This story begins with EDWARD III, who an-
doubtedlv promoted some industries by bringing alien
artisans into competition with domestic gilds. It con-
tinues with the theory that ELIZABETH I. adopted the pat-
ent monopoly as a general tool. Supposedly the institution
had been tried to some small extent on the Continent, but
it is asserted.that CF.cm and BACON, the Queen's advisors,
used it systematically for the first time. CoKEF undoubt-
l So mainly 1. D. Collier, Law of Patents, 1803, p. 9-15 and his followers,
like W. C. Robinson, Law of Patents, 1890, vol. I p. I-8. Robinson is still
cited as authority for the matter in question; for instance by 1. C. Stedman,
Law & Contemp. Probl., 1947 p. 652.
2 It was developed mainly by E. W. Hulme, Engineering 1894 p. 804
(unsigned); same, Law Quarterly Review 1896 p. 141, 1897 p. 313, 1900
p. 44, 1902 p. 280. 1917 p. 63, 180: E. F. Churchill, LQR 1925 p. 275: and
D. S. Davies, LOR 1932 p. 394, 1934 p. 86, 260. Some details were added
by I'. II. Price, The English Patents of Monopoly, 1906; C. T. Carr,
Select Charters. 1913; and H. G. Fox, Monopolies and Patents. 1947.
About CECIL and BACON see Davies 1932 p. 396, 1934 p. 271; Fox p. 3,
4. 163-175 etc. About COKE and his influence upon the Statute of Monop-
olies see mainly IV. S. Iloldsworth, LQR 1936 p. 481.