About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



32 Loy. Consumer L. Rev. 45 (2019-2020)
Scouring Muddied Waters: Towards Clarifying the CFPB's "Abusive" Practices

handle is hein.journals/lyclr32 and id is 53 raw text is: SCOURING MUDDIED WATERS:
TOWARDS CLARIFYING THE CFPB's
ABUSIVE PRACTICES
Michael R. Faz*
While this Article was pending publication, several events
unfolded altering the landscape of the abusive power. As a
preliminary note, during the pendency of publication several
dispositions changed-either by court order or agreement between
the parties.
Next, in June 2019, Director Kraninger kicked off the
Bureau's symposium series by holding an open forum over the
abusive power. The symposium consisted of two panels: one
focusing on policy, composed of law professors, and one focusing on
practical application, comprised of practicing attorneys in private
and  government practice. Both panels were intellectually
stimulating and presented diverging views. In the policy panel,
major disagreement arose in two areas: (1) whether the abusive
prong required consumer harm and (2) whether abusive contains a
scienter requirement. Further, the practical panel debated on the
issue of whether the abusive power needs clarification right now.
The panel did not come to an agreement, however, it made one
thing clear: there is widespread disagreement on whether
rulemaking is necessary to clarify the abusive power. This Article
will address that disagreement.
Finally, on September 7, 2019, Kraninger brought her first
abusive (with deceptive) action against Certified Forensic Loan
Auditors, LLC. This case shows Kraninger's willingness to use the
abusive power. This action, though, leaves open the question of
* Michael R. Faz, Juris Doctor Candidate 2020, University of Nebraska
College of Law; B.A., 2017, Texas A&M University-Commerce. First and
foremost, the author thanks his parents, Kim and Jesus Solis, for their
guidance and support. Further, the author thanks Professor Catherine Wilson
at the University of Nebraska College of Law for her assistance in this Article
and for her mentorship in cultivating the author's interest in financial
regulation and related areas.

45