About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



2017 U. Ill. J.L. Tech. & Pol'y 1 (2017)
Reforming and Specifying Intellectual Property Rights Policies of Standard-Setting Organizations: Towards Fair and Efficient Patent Licensing and Dispute Resolution

handle is hein.journals/jltp2017 and id is 7 raw text is: 








REFORMING AND SPECIFYING

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS

POLICIES OF STANDARD-SETTING

ORGANIZATIONS: TOWARDS FAIR AND

EFFICIENT PATENT LICENSING AND

DISPUTE RESOLUTION*

                                                               Richard Lit
                                                   Richard  Li-dar Wangtt


                                  Abstract
     Standard-setting organizations (SSOs) rely on commitments to license on
fair, reasonable, and  non-discriminatory  (FRAND)   terms  from  standard-
essential patent (SEP)  holders to ensure  access to standards and  prevent
potential anticompetitive conduct that unreasonably  enforces SEPs  against
standard  implementers. A substantial number of SEP  disputes, however have
been  raised unceasingly in recent years. In this Article s research, a statistical
analysis of the SEP  litigation cases in the United States from 2000 to 2014
shows  that the SEP disputes are closely related to the FRAND licensing terms
that are required in the intellectual property rights (IPR) policies of the SSOs
in  the  information  and  communications   technology        (ICT) sector    In
accordance   with opinions to date from  the U.S. Court  of Appeals for the
Federal   Circuit, the  U.S.  International  Trade  Commission,   the  U.S.
competition authorities, the European Commission, and the Court ofJustice of
the European   Union, there is no per se rule that prohibits seeking injunctive
relief against SEP infringement. Nonetheless, the criteria to decide whether to
grant  injunctive relief are different among various forums.   In principle,
injunctive relief should not be granted against a standard implementer who is


     *  This Article draws heavily on the first author's thesis for an LL.M. degree from National Chiao
 Tung University (Hsinchu, Taiwan), of which the second author is the lead advisor. Special thanks to three
 interviewees for their valuable opinions based on their ten to twenty years of experience in standard setting and
 patent license negotiations.
     t  Richard Li is a senior R&D engineer with a transnational smartphone company headquartered in
 Taiwan, focusing mainly on innovative research of advanced wireless communication technologies, standard
 setting in 3GPP RAN WGI, and patent analysis for SEP licensing; Ph.D. in Electrical Engineering, National
 Chung Cheng University (Chia-yi, Taiwan); LL.M., National Chiao Tung University (Hsinchu, Taiwan).
    tt  Richard Li-dar Wang is Associate Professor of Law at the National Chengchi University (Taipei,
 Taiwan); S.J.D. 2007, Indiana University Maurer School of Law (at Bloomington).


I