About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



5 J.L. & Innovation 38 (2023)
Understanding Criminal Justice Innovations

handle is hein.journals/jlinno5 and id is 41 raw text is: JOURNAL

OF
LAW & INNOVATION
C 2023 Journal of Law & Innovation
VOL. 5                     JANUARY 2023                      No. 1
ARTICLE
Understanding Criminal Justice Innovations
MEGHAN J. RYANt
Burgeoning science and technology have provided the criminal justice
system with the opportunity to address some of its shortcomings. And the
criminal justice system has significant shortcomings. Among other issues, we
have a mass incarceration problem; clearance rates are surprisingly low;
there are serious concerns about wrongful convictions; and the system is
layered with racial, religious, and other biases. Innovations that are widely
used across industries, as well as those directed specifically at the criminal
justice system, have the potential to improve upon such problems. But it is
important to recognize that these innovations also have downsides, and
criminal justice actors must proceed with caution and understand not only
the potential of these interventions but also their limitations. Relevant to this
calculation of caution is whether the innovation is broadly used across
industry sectors or, rather, whether it has been specifically developedfor use
within the criminal justice system. These latter innovations have a record of
not being sufficiently vetted for accuracy and reliability. Accordingly,
t Associate Dean for Research, Robert G. Storey Distinguished Faculty Fellow, Gerald
J. Ford Research Fellow, Altshuler Distinguished Teaching Professor, and Professor of Law,
SMU Dedman School of Law. I thank David Abrams and Gerald Adams for the kind
invitation to be part of this great symposium. I also thank Aurelie Ouss, Hillel Bavli, Jenia
Turner, and the symposium participants for their generous comments on this piece and
thoughtful discussions about criminal justice innovations more broadly.