About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



55 Harv. C.R.-C.L. L. Rev. 1 (2020)
The Treatment-Industrial Complex: Alternative Corrections, Private Prison Companies, and Criminal Justice Debt

handle is hein.journals/hcrcl55 and id is 7 raw text is: The Treatment-Industrial Complex: Alternative
Corrections, Private Prison Companies,
and Criminal Justice Debt
Laura I Appleman *
Out of the 6.7 million adults caught up in the criminal legal system, approx-
imately 4.5 million are under correctional control outside of prisons and jails.
Within this hidden world of alternative corrections, people who are arrested,
detained, imprisoned, put on probation or diversion, and even released are
forced to pay a growing amount of money to various for-profit criminal jus-
tice actors. Alternatives to incarceration are conditioned on fines, fees, and
other forms of wealth extraction, causing a vicious cycle of poverty and indebt-
edness that is virtually impossible to escape. This Article explores and analyzes
the little-researched area of criminal justice debt arising from alternative cor-
rections: how private corrections companies profit from supervising those indi-
viduals released, paroled, sent to rehabilitation or diversion, placed on
probation, or subject to forensic or civil commitment. These under-examined
forms of for-profit correctional supervision-the treatment-industrial com-
plex-have turned supposedly progressive alternatives to incarceration into
cash-register justice.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION    ......................................      .....  . ......  2
I. WHERE CASH IS KING: HOw PRIVATE ALTERNATIVE
CORRECTIONS BEGGARS THE POOR .......................            .   3
A. The Growth of Alternative Corrections ................           4
B. Private Probation Companies ........................             6
1.  Pay-Only   Probation  .............................        8
2.  Drug and Alcohol Testing ........................          9
3.  Long-term Private Monitoring ...................          10
C. Drug Rehabilitation and Halfway Houses .............            12
1.  Drug and Alcohol Rehabilitation .................         13
2. Rehabilitation in Free Labor: Forced Labor as
Treatm ent  ......... ..............................     18
D. Mental Illness and Forensic Mental Healthcare ........          23
E. For-Profit Diversion Programs .......................           28
* Associate Dean of Faculty Research and Van Winkle Melton Professor of Law, Willam-
ette University. J.D., Yale University; B.A., M.A., Univ. of Pennsylvania. Thank you to David
Friedman, Cynthia Godsoe, Brian Highsmith, Alexis Karterton, Lauren Ouizel, Jocelyn Simon-
son, Kate Weisburd, and the exemplary editors of the Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law
Review for your thoughtful comments and edits. Thanks also to Willamette for its research
support.