About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



47 Colum. J. Transnat'l L. 6 (2008-2009)
Balancing Security, Democracy, and Human Rights in an Age of Terrorism

handle is hein.journals/cjtl47 and id is 8 raw text is: Balancing Security, Democracy, and Human
Rights in an Age of Terrorism
SANDRA DAY O'CONNOR*
This speech was presented by Sandra Day O'Connor
upon receiving the Fall 2007 Wolfgang Friedmann
Award for Outstanding Contributions to the Field of
International Law in conjunction with the Harold Lev-
enthal Memorial Lecture Series on November 12,
2007.
I would like to open my remarks tonight by describing a con-
flict between the executive and judicial branches of the United States
government. Not long after the outbreak of war, the President of the
United States altered the traditional understanding of civil liberties by
finding that standard jury trials were incapable of meeting the neces-
sities of wartime. In an effort to remedy this situation, the executive
determined that some defendants should be tried by special military
courts rather than traditional juries. The United States Supreme
Court rejected that claim and found that the military courts lacked ju-
risdiction over those defendants who were U.S. citizens.
Now, this conflict sounds like it came directly from the New
York Times or the Washington Post. But instead of describing Presi-
dent George W. Bush and the War on Terror of today, I am describ-
ing President Abraham Lincoln and our Civil War of the 1860s.
President Lincoln decided that wartime needs required him to sus-
pend our constitutional right to a writ of habeas corpus. In Ex parte
Milligan, our Supreme Court held that military tribunals did not have
jurisdiction over civilians who were suspected of aiding the Confed-
eracy so long as the traditional civilian courts remained open and
functioning.' Justice David Davis's opinion for the Supreme Court
noted-in language that has taken on renewed resonance today-that
*  Associate Justice, Retired, Supreme Court of the United States.
1. 71 U.S. (4 Wall.) 2, 3 (1866).