About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



26 Wayne L. Rev. 1067 (1979-1980)
Commercial Transactions - Michigan Rejects UCC and Adopts Minority Common Law Standard for Conditional Check Accord and Satisfaction

handle is hein.journals/waynlr26 and id is 1069 raw text is: COMMERCIAL TRANSACTIONS-MICHIGAN
REJECTS UCC AND ADOPTS MINORITY
COMMON LAW STANDARD FOR
CONDITIONAL CHECK ACCORD AND
SATISFACTION
Defendant orally agreed to purchase 20,000 bushels of corn from
plaintiff, and contracted, in turn, to resell the corn on the Chicago
market. The corn, however, was not of the quality expected, and
defendant made arrangements to sell it on the Toledo market, where a
higher price could be obtained for the lower grade crop.' Defendant
tendered a check to plaintiff for the contract price, less consequential
damages arising from his discharge of his contractual obligation with a
Chicago broker. A printed statement and a written notation on the
check indicated that defendant considered it payment in full.2 After
discussions with defendant failed to resolve the dispute, plaintiff
struck out the written notation, deposited the check, and filed suit in
district court to recover the balance.3 Defendant's affirmative defense
at trial, and his contention on appeal, was that an accord and satisfac-
tion had discharged the balance as a matter of law.4 The circuit court
was persuaded by defendant's argument, and reversed the jury's ver-
1. Defendant had notified plaintiff that a better price could be received for
the corn on the Toledo market, and a contract price of $1.24 or $1.25 was agreed on.
Fritz v. Maranette, 404 Mich. 329, 332, 273 N.W.2d 425, 426 (1978). Defendant
claimed, however, that the supplemental contract price was approximately $1.30,
less what it costs to buy corn to pay off the Chicago contract. Appellee's brief at 2.
Defendant further alleged that the corn was not merely of an inferior grade, but was
badly damaged. Id.
2. The check, for $15,252.21, represented payment of the $24,000 contract
price as reduced by the Chicago damages. 404 Mich. at 332, 273 N.W.2d at 426. The
printed statement was: 'By endorsement this check when paid is accepted in full pay-
ment of the following account.' Beneath the print was a written notation 'Corn con-
tract paid in full.' Id.
3. Defendant contended that plaintiff had agreed to the deduction prior to
the shipment of corn. Appellee's brief at 2. Plaintiff, however, alleged that an agree-
ment had been reached that no deduction would be made. Appellant's brief at 3.
4. MICH. COMP. LAWS ANN. § 566.1 (1967) provides:
An agreement hereafter made to change or modify, or to discharge in
whole or in part, any contract, obligation, or lease, or any mortgage or other
security interest in personal or real property, shall not be invalid because of
the absence of consideration: Provided, That the agreement changing,
modifying, or discharging such contract, obligation, lease, mortgage or
security interest shall not be valid or binding unless it shall be in writing and
signed by the party against whom it is sought to enforce the change,
modification, or discharge.
The instant court did not address the applicability of the statute. It was, however,
applied to conditional check accord and satisfaction in Belt v. Wolpin Co., 39 Mich.
App. 40, 197 N.W.2d 129, leave to appeal denied, 368 Mich. 786 (1972).

1067