About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



22 B.U. L. Rev. 375 (1942)
Equivalent Elimination Agreements in Public Housing Projects

handle is hein.journals/bulr22 and id is 377 raw text is: EQUIVALENT ELIMINATION AGREEMENTS
IN PUBLIC HOUSING PROJECTS
JOHN I. ROBINSON* AND SOPHIE ROBINSON ALTMAN**
Prior to the initiation of the public housing program, only a spas-
modic, and usually abortive, interest could be excited on behalf of the
elimination of unsafe and insanitary structures by compulsion. Gen-
erally, any such activity could be attributed to some catastrophe or
near tragedy.' Despite the existence of remedial legislation,2 little,
if any, thought or action was applied to the possibilities of arresting
or erasing the evils of congestion, insanitation and dilapidation by
compulsory demolition or repair. Massachusetts has been no excep-
*B.A. Yale, 1924; LL.B. Yale Law School, 1926; Editor, Yale Law Journal
1925-1926; Member, Massachusetts Bar; Division Counsel, National Recovery
Administration, Washington, D. C., 1934; Member, Massachusetts State Board of
Housing; Author, Trustees' Investments in Massachusetts, 14 BosToN UNivERSry
LAW REVIEW 88, Public Housing in Massachusetts, 18 BOSTON UNIVERSITY LAW
REVIEW 83.
**B.A. Wellesley, 1933; LL.B. Yale Law School 1936; Member, District of
Columbia Bar; Attorney General's Survey on Relief Procedures, 1936-1937;
Bureau of Rehabilitation, 1937-1938.
1In his Slums and Housing, James Ford refers to an illustrative incident:
This particular legislation (amendments to the Multiple Dwelling Law)
is illustrative of how a certain amount of exaggeration in publicity may
bring about improvement in housing conditions-provided that the resultant
law is enforced. In the late winter and early spring of 1934, a period of
exceptionally severe weather, an unusual number of fatal fires occurred in
old-law tenements. The circumstances were made the occasion for a spec-
tacular campaign against 'firetraps' culminating in the passage of a law
requiring fire-retarding of walls, the separation of stairways from apartments,
and other measures intended to reduce fire hazards. As a matter of fact, the
construction of the buildings and the nature of the exits had nothing to do
with a majority of the losses of life, but the publicity was effective in bring-
ing about improvements that should have been required years before and
could have been installed then with less financial embarrassment to the owners.
Ford, Slums and Housing (1936), Vol. II, p. 619.
'This does not mean, however, that all such restrictive legislation is adequate
and workable. Many of the States have extremely sketchy provisions or restrict
enforcement to dangerous or unsafe structures. See infra. See also Report No.
37, June, 1938, Institute of Municipal Law Officers; and Report No. 39, August,
1938. The United States Housing Authority has drafted and secured the passage
of a detailed and co6rdinating slum clearance bill in Louisiana, Mississippi, North
Carolina, South Carolina, Tennessee, Vermont and Puerto Rico. (These are to
be distinguished from the Housing Authorities and Housing Cobperation Laws.)
However, this bill has never been submitted to the General Court. Pursuant to
a Resolve (Chapter 71, Acts of 1941) Governor Saltonstall has appointed a Recess
Commission to study and investigate the legislation advisable in order to require
the owners of tenements and other dwellings leased or rented for human habita-
tion to bring them up to certain standards to promote the health and well being
of persons residing therein.