About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



68 S. Cal. L. Rev. 1447 (1994-1995)
Steadying the Court's Unsteady Path: A Theory of Judicial Enforcement of Federalism

handle is hein.journals/scal68 and id is 1463 raw text is: ARTICLE
STEADYING THE COURT'S
UNSTEADY PATH:
A THEORY OF JUDICIAL
ENFORCEMENT OF FEDERALISM
JENNA BEDNAR*
WILLIAM N. ESKRIDGE, JR.**
Like the Supreme Court's separation of powers jurisprudence, its
federalism jurisprudence might, uncharitably, be described as a
mess.' The Court's decisions setting forth jurisdictional limitations
on national power have waffled famously. Taken as a whole, they
flunk requirements of either good law or good policy: The decisions
are inconsistent with constitutional text and with one another, and
they lack a persuasive normative theory to justify the first inconsis-
tency or to resolve the second. These difficulties are rehearsed in the
six different opinions the Justices rendered in United States v. Lopez,
where a fractured Court invalidated a federal statute that made it a
crime to possess a firearm in proximity to a school.
* Ph.D. Candidate, Stanford University, Department of Political Science.
** Professor of Law, Georgetown University Law Center.
Earlier versions of this Article were presented in workshops at the law schools of Stanford
University and Washington University, and the last draft was presented at the conference organ-
ized by the California Institute of Technology and the University of Southern California Law
Center. We appreciate comments from participants in those workshops. We received particu-
larly detailed and usefully critical comments from William Cohen, Barbara Fried, Gerald Gun-
ther (our gracious commentator and presenter at the Stanford workshop), Mark Kelman, Ron
Levin, Bruce La Pierre, Margaret Radin, and Emerson Tiller (our gracious commentator at the
CIT-USC conference). John Ferejohn, widely known as the high priest of rational choice, is
the intellectual parent of our work, and to him we are grateful for both comments and
inspiration.
1. Cf. Stephen Carter, The Independent Counsel Mess, 102 HARv. L. REV. 105 (1988).
2. 115 S. Ct. 1624 (1995).

1447