About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



88 Tul. L. Rev. 1071 (2013-2014)
Fraud and Abuse in Mesothelioma Litigation

handle is hein.journals/tulr88 and id is 1151 raw text is: Fraud and Abuse in Mesothelioma Litigation
Lester Brickman*
I. NTRODUCTION..................................... 1072
H.   THE ENTREPRENEURIAL MODEL OF NONMALIGNANT
CASE GENERATION         ............................. .....1090
111. THE DUAL COMPENSArfON SYSTEM IN MALIGNANT
LITIGATION........................................1096
A. Plaintiffs' Counsels Control over the Formation and
Opeiadon ofBankuptcy Trusts...........        .....1097
B. TDP Provisions Designed To Preclude Defendants'
Access to Evidence of Other Exposures ............... 1099
C    Rule 2019 Statements    ................   ............. 1107
D    Master Ballots.     ......................      ..... 1110
E    The Kananian Case........................1112
E    Other Examples ofSuppression ofEvidence of
Exposures to the Products ofReorganized
Companies         ........................    ..... 1115
1.   Lies, Damned Lies, and Discovery Responses ......1116
2.   Delaying Filing of Trust Claims ........ ........1117
3.   The Strategy Behind Delayed Production of
Trust Claim Filings.....................1118
4.   Specious Explanations for Failure To Disclose......1119
5.   Montgomery v American Steel & Wire Corp........1121
G.   The Results of Garlock   m Lhnited Discovery.................. 1122
1H   The Extent ofSuppression ofExposure Evidence......... 1125
I    The Effect ofInconsistent Trust Clahns on
Payments to Trust Claimants..........      .............. 1126
J    The Source of the Scheme To Suppress Evidence of
Exposure to the Products ofReorganized
Companies         ........................    ..... 1127
K    The Philadelphia Story....        .................1 129
IV   THE STATUS OF MESOTHELIOMA LITIGATION AND THE
CONFLICTING ROLES OF REFERRAL COUNSEL AND TRIAL
COUNSEL          .................................... .....1 131
*    0 2014 Lester Brickman. Professor of Law, Benjamin N. Cardozo School of
Law of Yeshiva University. I would like to acknowledge the invaluable assistance of my
research assistants: Greg Brown, Chris Ilardi, and Kayla Robinson.
1071