About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



42 U. Pitt. L. Rev. 939 (1980-1981)
Medical Malpractice Screening Panels: A Judicial Evaluation of Their Practical Effect

handle is hein.journals/upitt42 and id is 949 raw text is: MEDICAL MALPRACTICE SCREENING PANELS: A
JUDICIAL EVALUATION OF THEIR PRACTICAL EFFECT
To the student of government, bureaucracy is a term used to
describe the structure of administrative organizations which fall
under the dominion of the executive branch of our government.
However, in contemporary usage, the term is much less neutral
and specialized. Bureaucracy is commonly used to characterize
any governmental structure we dislike; it connotes delay, expense,
waste, and frustration. Partial responsibility for the creation of bu-
reaucratic structures must be shouldered by the state and federal
legislatures. Often, an intended legislative solution to a social prob-
lem results in the creation of a bureaucracy. The most recent legis-
lative creature to be labeled bureaucratic is the medical mal-
practice screening panel.' At times, bureaucratic solutions do
produce the result desired, but in the case of screening panels,
which were once touted by proponents as a panacea for the medi-
cal malpractice crisis,2 the resulting effects were not those which
were legislatively intended.
Screening panels, a product of the medical malpractice crisis,
are a pretrial device designed to weed out frivolous medical mal-
practice claims and to encourage early settlement of non-frivolous
ones. Pennsylvania, like many other states during the height of the
nationwide legislative search for a solution to the medical malprac-
tice crisis, statutorily adopted the screening panel as one facet of
its comprehensive program for combating the situation.3 Shortly
after the statute was passed the Pennsylvania Supreme Court held
that screening panels were constitutionally permissible. After only
four years of use, however, data revealed that screening panels
were ineffective and, in fact, often counterproductive. In Mattos v.
Thompson,5 the Pennsylvania Supreme Court reconsidered the
1. See Parker v. Children's Hosp., 483 Pa. 106, 132, 394 A.2d 932, 945 (1978) (Larsen,
J., dissenting); National Law Journal, Feb. 4, 1980 at 1, col 1.
2. For a discussion of the medical malpractice crisis and its causes, see Roth, The
Medical Malpractice Insurance Crisis: Its Causes, The Effects, And Proposed Solutions, 44
INS. COUNSEL J. 469 (1977).
3. Health Care Services Malpractice Act, 40 PA. CONS. STAT. ANN. §§ 1301.101-.1006
(Purdon Supp. 1980) [hereinafter cited as HCSMA].
4. Parker v. Children's Hasp., 483 Pa. 106, 394 A.2d 932 (1978).
5. - Pa. -, 421 A.2d 190 (1980).