About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



89 Wash. L. Rev. 1155 (2014)
Compensated Surrogacy

handle is hein.journals/washlr89 and id is 1185 raw text is: COMPENSATED SURROGACY

Martha A. Field
INTRODUCTION
The question that was put to us is whether the widespread legalization
of gay marriage, supported by the Supreme Court's decision in United
States v. Windsor,' means that compensated surrogacy should be more
broadly legalized. This essay takes the position that Windsor has little
relevance to surrogacy, which will continue to be governed by state
rather than federal law. States do, and will, follow a wide spectrum of
policies on surrogacy, ranging from banning it and making it illegal to
promoting it by enforcing surrogacy contracts as ordinary commercial
transactions. The legalization of gay marriage need not affect states'
surrogacy laws.
It is easy to understand why gay couples want to be able to have
genetically related babies; their reasons are the same as other couples',
and the desire is widespread. Why would anyone want to interfere with a
procedure that helps create loving and happy families and allows many
men, single or married, to have a genetically related child? From that
perspective, it seems cruel to deny this procedure to gay male couples, to
couples in which the wife is infertile, or to single persons, for that
matter.2
But surrogacy is not problem-free. It raises serious issues of
commodification-of sex, of childbirth, of birthmothers, and of
children-by allowing contracts, sales, and money to govern these once
noncommercialized areas of life. Such commercialization of childbirth
could profoundly affect the kind of society in which we live. Surrogacy
also arguably exploits women instead of liberating them. Accordingly
the calls to legalize surrogacy further are joined by calls to eliminate
Langdell Professor of Law, Harvard University. I wish to thank Rachel Silverman Dolphin for
excellent research assistance.
1.   U.S.   , 133 S. Ct. 2675 (2013).
2. Couples in which only the male is infertile and most lesbian couples will not require surrogacy;
they will simply have to purchase sperm and undergo artificial insemination, an easier and less
expensive procedure that raises fewer ethical concerns.

1155