About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



69 Tex. L. Rev. 1001 (1990-1991)
Original Intent in Historical Perspective: Some Critical Glosses

handle is hein.journals/tlr69 and id is 1023 raw text is: Texas Law Review
Volume 69,     Number 5,      April 1991
Original Intent in Historical Perspective:
Some Critical Glosses
Hans W. Baade*
As the debate over originalism in constitutional interpretation has raged in legal
literature over the past several years, attention has occasionally been focused on the
understanding of the framers of the Constitution as to the canons of interpretation to
be applied to their words. The originalist call for historical ascertainment of the actual
intent of those who drafted the Constitution has been countered by the argument that
the very intent of the Founding Fathers included no expectation of a continued
originalist commitment to their subjective intent. Using that debate as a point of
departure, Professor Baade in this Article undertakes the broader task of tracing the
history of judicial reliance on extrinsic evidence for the determination of legislative
intent and constitutional meaning. He describes the prevalence of the common-law
rule of nonrecourse to legislative history in the late eighteenth century, chronicles the
continued but declining viability of that rule in nineteenth-century constitutional and
statutory interpretation in the United States, and finally traces its demise in the post-
New Deal era against the backdrop of growth in statutory regulation, bureaucratic
administration, and legislative oversight
I.  Eighteenth-Century Common-Law Rules of Legislative
Interpretation  ............................................ 1006
A.   The English Rule of No Recourse .................. 1006
B.   The English Rule in Post-Revolutionary America .... 1008
C.   The Legislative Documentation Factor ................. 1011
II.  The Constitutional Dimension ............................ 1013
A.   Statutes and Constitutions ............................ 1013
B.   The Jay's Treaty Debates of 1796 ..................... 1014
C    Madison and the First Bank .......................... 1022
III.  Early Nineteenth-Century Sequels: Story, Marshall, and
M adison  .................................................      1023
A.   Intertemporal Considerations ......................... 1023
* Hugh Lamar Stone Chair in Civil Law, University of Texas School of Law. A.B. 1949,
Syracuse University; D. IUR. 1951, University of Kiel; LL.B., LL.M. 1955, Duke University; Di-
ploma 1956, The Hague Academy of International Law.

1001