About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



48 U.C.D. L. Rev. 1509 (2014-2015)
Patents, Partnerships, and the Pre-Competitive Collaboration Myth in Pharmaceutical Innovation

handle is hein.journals/davlr48 and id is 1535 raw text is: 









        Patents, Partnerships, and the

  Pre-Competitive Collaboration Myth

         in Pharmaceutical Innovation

                           Liza S. Vertinsky*

   Public-private partnerships offer a promising alternative paradigm for
 pharmaceutical innovation in complex disease areas where there are both
 strong commercial interests and significant public need. They have the
 potential to reduce the tremendous waste associated with duplicative
 unsuccessful drug development efforts and to encourage the sharing of
 knowledge essential to accelerate pharmaceutical innovation. Patents
 threaten the potential of partnership strategies, however, by making it
 harder to sustain robust systems of knowledge sharing. Policymakers have
 tried to avoid this problem by focusing partnership strategies on areas
 deemed   to be pre-competitive -     areas of   collaboration without
 competition and typically also without patents.
   This Article suggests that the current pre-competitive approach to
partnership strategies in pharmaceutical innovation is fundamentally
flawed for two reasons. First, it ignores the competitive market pressures
that both shape what is deemed to be pre-competitive and fuel tensions


      Copyright © 2015 Liza S. Vertinsky. Associate Professor of Law, Emory
University School of Law. Many thanks to Timothy Holbrook, Timothy Terrell, Yaniv
Heled, Cynthia Ho, Kevin Outterson, and Michael Carroll, as well as Sean O'Connor,
Roger Ford, Dan Burk, Mark McKenna, and other participants of the Yale Innovation
Beyond IP conference 2014; Arti Rai, Jerome Reichman, Katherine Strandburg, Brett
Frischmann, Michael Madison, Peter Lee, Margaret Chon, Sonali Shah, and the other
participants in the Medical Commons Workshop at NYU in May 2014 and the 2nd
Thematic Conference on the Knowledge Commons at NYU in September 2014;
participants in the summer workshop at Georgia State College of Law in July 2014;
participants of the Emory Faculty Colloquium; Simon Stern, Abraham Drassinower,
Margaret J. Radin, Trudo Lemmens, and other participants in the University of
Toronto Innovation Law & Policy Workshop in October 2014; Joshua Sarnoff and
participants in DePaul's Manzo Scholars in Patent Law workshop in March 2015; and
participants in the St. John's Law School IP Colloquium in March 2015 for their
valuable comments and ideas. Special thanks also to Abigail Rives, Laura Powell, and
Lauren Ulrich for their valuable research assistance.


1509