About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



49 Cornell L. Q. 346 (1963-1964)
Real Property: Landlord and Tenant: Clauses Prohibiting Subleasing without the Landlord's Consent: Dress Skirt Sales, Inc. v. Hotel Martinique Associates, 12 N.Y.2d 339, 190 N.E.2d 10, 239 N.Y.S.2d 660 (1963)

handle is hein.journals/clqv49 and id is 368 raw text is: CORNELL LAW QUARTERLY

donees in general in the present interest situation, these limitations are func-
tional and just, and by abolishing the common-law limitation on the wife-
donee, placing her on a par with other donees, the court has achieved a victory
over a formal and unjust anachronism.
Grant Anderson
Real Property: Landlord and Tenant: Clauses Prohibiting Subleasing
Without the Landlord's Consent: Dress Shirt Sales, Inc. v. Hotel Martinique
Associates, 12 N.Y.2d 339, 190 N.E.2d 10, 239 N.Y.S.2d 660 (1963).-
The lease in issue prohibited subleasing of the premises without the written
consent of the lessors, the defendants. When the plaintiffs could no longer make
use of the premises, the defendants assured them of their willingness to allow
a subleasing, and plaintiffs displayed a for rent sign on the premises with
defendants' consent. Defendants, however, refused to accept the specific sub-
lessee plaintiffs proposed, purportedly disapproving of the use the sublessee was
to make of the premises. The defendants then exacted $30,000 (considerably
less than the rent that would become due during the remainder of the term)
from the plaintiffs for cancellation of the lease and shortly thereafter leased
the premises to the sublessee that the plaintiff had originally proposed at a
higher rental than the plaintiff had been paying. The plaintiffs brought an action
for damages based on the lessors' arbitrary refusal of consent, for breach of
an oral agreement to permit subleasing, and for fraud in the negotiations leading
to cancellation of the lease. In the trial court, defendants' motion for summary
judgment was denied, but the appellate division reversed, granted the motion,
and directed entry of judgment dismissing the complaint. The Court of Appeals
affirmed. It stated that the provision against subleasing without the lessors' con-
sent permitted the lessors to refuse their consent arbitrarily and that the oral
agreement was invalid under N.Y. Real Prop. Law section 2822 since the lease
provided that no part could be changed or waived orally. The court found noth-
ing to support plaintiffs' suggestion that defendants' permission to display a
for rent sign was an executed waiver and advance acceptance of any new
tenant. In regard to plaintiffs' contention that defendants acted fraudulently,
the court noted that plaintiffs were released from liability for future rent pay-
ments amounting to a sum considerably larger than the $30,000 paid by plain-
tiffs for the release. The court reasoned that the only way in which the plaintiffs
could establish that they had in fact suffered a loss entitling them to damages
was to demonstrate that if they had known that the defendants were not as
insistent on holding plaintiffs to their lease as their representations made them
appear, plaintiffs could have made a more favorable bargain in obtaining the
release. The court, however, denied the right to relief because of its policy of
1 16 App. Div. 2d 899, 228 N.Y.S.2d 807 (1st Dep't 1962).
2 Subdivision 1 of N.Y. Real Prop. Law § 282 provides: An executory agreement hereafter
made shall be ineffective to change or modify, or to discharge in whole or in part, a written
agreement or other written instrument hereafter executed which contains a provision to the
effect that it cannot be changed orally, unless such executory agreement is in writing and
signed by the party against whom enforcement of the change, modification or discharge is
sought or by his agent.

[Vol. 49