About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



11 Cardozo L. Rev. 803 (1989-1990)
A Discussion between Junius Scales, Telford Taylor, and David Rudenstine

handle is hein.journals/cdozo11 and id is 817 raw text is: A DISCUSSION BETWEEN JUNIUS SCALES, TELFORD TAYLOR, AND
DAVID RUDENSTINE*
David Rudenstine: Mr. Scales, maybe you could start by telling
us about the original indictment, what you were charged with and
your reaction to it.
Junius Scales: I didn't like it! In 1954, I was a very active party
organizer and was what was called underground, which meant I
was as unavailable to FBI surveillance as possible. I was traveling
over North Carolina, South Carolina, Virginia, Tennessee, and north-
ern Mississippi. That was my territory. I was planning a week's visit
in Memphis and I found out later from studying FBI freedom of in-
formation records that every office east of Kansas was required to
report weekly, some of them daily, on whether they had any leads as
to where I might be. Finally, they got word from an informer in
Memphis that I was coming to Memphis. They tried to catch me
before because catching me in Memphis meant giving away a per-
fectly good informer, but they weren't successful and so they had to
wait until I came to the rendezvous. Then I was arrested and I found
that the indictment had been returned that afternoon in North
Wilkesboro, North Carolina. I couldn't get a copy. It was at least
two weeks before I even got a copy of it. So everyone knew more
about it than I did.
Rudenstine: Could you give just a real quick idea about what it
means to be underground? You describe it as being able to move
about without being detected by the FBI. How do you go about doing
that?
Scales: Well, I had a million tricks. If I was going from New
York down to Memphis, I went to Cincinnati the first day, spent the
night in Cincinnati and took a Greyhound bus down to Memphis.
When I got to the edge of Memphis, I got off the bus and got on a
trolley. Then I got off the trolley and went through a park where the
zoo was and where nobody could drive through. I then caught a bus
just pulling up. I went into the middle of town, took a cab in the
opposite direction, went through a large store, came out of there and
went in to a movie theatre and sat in the men's room making notes
until it was dark. And then I went to this rendezvous, where I was
* On March 2, 1988, Junius Scales and Telford Taylor were guests of Professor David
Rudenstine at his seminar on Free Speech and National Security at the Benjamin N. Cardozo
School of Law. The topic discussed was Scales v. United States, 367 U.S. 203 (1961). The
original transcription has been edited slightly for publication. Professor Rudenstine wishes to
thank Sandra L. Cobden (Cardozo 1990) for assuming the responsibility of footnoting the
transcript.