About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



85 Cornell L. Rev. 1358 (1999-2000)
Gay Rights for Gay Whites: Race, Sexual Identity, and Equal Protection Discourse

handle is hein.journals/clqv85 and id is 1366 raw text is: GAY RIGHTS FOR GAY WHITES?:
RACE, SEXUAL IDENTITY, AND
EQUAL PROTECTION DISCOURSE
Darren Lenard Hutchinsont
INTRODUCTION
The issue of gay and lesbian legal equality remains unresolved
and highly contested.' Despite the vigorous efforts of gay and lesbian
activists and theorists and the recent, apparent broadening of public
support for protecting gays and lesbians in formal civil rights struc-
tures,2 the legal status of gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgendered in-
dividuals remains largely unequal and unprotected. For instance, no
federal court of appeals has applied heightened scrutiny when hear-
t  Assistant Professor of Law, Southern Methodist University. BA., 1990, University of
Pennsylvania; J.D., 1993, Yale Law School. I have had several opportunities to present ear-
lier versions of this Article, and I am grateful for the helpful comments I received at these
forums. Specifically, this Article benefitted from comments received at faculty workshops
at Colorado, Southern Methodist, Stanford, and Villanova Law Schools, and from presenta-
tions at the 1999 Queer Ethnic Studies Conference at the University of California at Berke-
ley, the 1999 Latino and Latina Critical Legal Theory Conference, a 1999 DePaul Law
School antisubordination conference, and the 1999 Law and Society Annual Meeting. I
am particularly indebted to Martha Fineman for inviting me to present a draft at the 1999
Feminism and Legal Theory Workshop at Cornell Law School. The following individuals
provided stimulating comments at these forums or otherwise: Michelle Anderson, Elvia
Arriola, Paul Brest, William Bridge, Jennifer Gerrarda Brown, Harlon L. Dalton, David
Cruz, Richard Ford, Katherine Franke, Clark Freshman, Jeffrey Gaba, Isabelle Gunning,
Pamela Karlan, George Martinez, Teemu Ruskola, Daniel Shuman, Terry Smith, and Rich-
ard C. Turkington. I apologize to any persons whose input I have neglected to acknowl-
edge. Barbara Nicholas, Michael Smith, and Darlene Woodson provided excellent
research assistance. Southern Methodist University provided financial assistance for this
project.
1  See generally EVAN GERSTMANN, THE CONSITUTIONAL UNDERcLAss: GAYs, LEsBIANS,
AND THE FAILURE OF CLAss-BASED EQUAL PRoTEanoN 3-39 (1999) (analyzing the
subordinate status of gays and lesbians within equal protection doctrine). By equality I
refer to the inclusion of gays, lesbians, bisexuals, and transgendered individuals in antidis-
crimination law and policy at the state and federal level. I do not, however, limit the term
equality simply to notions of formal equality, which is the focus of much antidiscrirnination
doctrine. Instead, I view the question of equality as a substantive and formal issue.
2 See Lisa M. Farabee, Note, Marriage, Equal Protection, and New Judicial Federalism: A
View from the States, 14 YALE L. & POL'Y R-v. 237, 270 (1996) (Public opinion has ...
become more supportive of gay rights in general.); see also id. at 270 n.174 (citing to
various polling data indicating increasing public support of gay and lesbian equality). The
public, however, is selective about which dimensions of gay rights agendas it supports.
See William A. Henry, III, Pride and Prejudice, TxssE, June 27, 1994, at 54, 58 (indicating
broad public support for antidiscrimination laws protecting gays and lesbians against job
discrimination but wide public opposition to efforts to legalize same-sex marriage).

1358