About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



29 Swiss. Rev. Int'l & Eur. L. 581 (2019)
Autonomous Weapons Systems and International Law: Aspects of International Humanitarian Law, Individual Accountability and State Responsibility

handle is hein.journals/sriel29 and id is 592 raw text is: 






Autonomous Weapons Systems and International Law:

Aspects of International Humanitarian Law,

Individual Accountability and State Responsibility



Yannick  Zerbe*




With the use of Artificial Intelligence, so-called Autonomous Weapons Systems could one day operate freely,
choosing and eliminating targets without human involvement. With the seemingly inevitable proliferation of
these systems, some will eventually violate International Humanitarian Law. Consequently, the establish-
ment of legal responsibility for potential war crimes will be seriously impeded by the absence of a human in
the command chain. Therefore, the individual responsibility regime under IHL would in many instances fail
to hold a military commander or manufacturer of an AWS responsible for its wrongful actions. However,
since the regime of state responsibility under the IHL framework does not require a mental element, it is
preferable to that of individual responsibility, in order to avoid accountability gaps for the actions of AWSs.
A strict responsibility regime for AWSs should furthermore be established to assure that states are held
responsible for any damage caused by their AWSs.

Keywords:   autonomous weapons system - international humanitarian law - state responsibility - weapon
            law - artificial intelligence - strict responsibility.


Table of Contents

I.   Introduction
II.  Compliance ofAutonomous   Weapons  Systems with IHL
     A. The Prohibition of Indiscriminate Weapons
     B. The Principle of Proportionality
     C. The Principle of Precautions in Attack
     D. The Principle of Military Necessity
     E. The Prohibition of Weapons that Cause Superfluous Injury or Unnecessary Suffering
     F. The Martens  Clause
     G. A Legal Requirement for Human  Control?
     H. Preliminary Findings on the Compliance ofAWSs  with IHL
III. The Problems of Individual Responsibility
     A. Commanding Officer   Responsibility
     B. Manufacturer  Responsibility








   Yannick Zerbe is a recent bachelor graduate of international relations at the University of Geneva. Con-
   tact: yannick.zerbeggmx.ch.


29 SRIEL  (2019)


581