About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



99 Harv. L. Rev. 668 (1985-1986)
Alternative Dispute Resolution: Panacea or Anathema

handle is hein.journals/hlr99 and id is 686 raw text is: COMMENTARY

ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION: PANACEA OR
ANATHEMA?
Hany T. Edwards*
The Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) movement has seen an
extraordinary transformation in the last ten years. Little more than
a decade ago, only a handful of scholars and attorneys perceived the
need for alternatives to litigation. The ADR idea was seen as nothing
more than a hobbyhorse for a few offbeat scholars. Today, with the
rise of public complaints about the inefficiencies and injustices of our
traditional court systems, the ADR movement has attracted a band-
wagon following of adherents. ADR is no longer shackled with the
reputation of a cult movement.
At worst, ADR is merely a highly fashionable idea, now viewed
as worthy of serious discussions among practitioners and scholars of
widely diverse backgrounds and professional interests. At best, the
ADR movement reflects a serious new effort to design workable and
fair alternatives to our traditional judicial systems. There can be no
doubt, however, that the ADR movement has drawn wide public
attention. During the past five years, there have been literally scores
of books, articles, conferences, bulletins, newsletters, and new course
offerings on ADR. Mechanisms for alternative dispute resolution are
now being established throughout the United States, with well over
one hundred and fifty minor dispute mediation centers in almost forty
states,' and court-annexed arbitration is now actively used in both
state and federal courts.2 These are indeed heady times for those in
the ADR movement. There is reason for concern, however, that the
bandwagon may be on a runaway course.
Popularity and public interest are not sure signs of a quality en-
deavor. This is certainly true of ADR, because the movement is ill-
defined and the motives of some ADR adherents are questionable. It
appears that some people have joined the ADR bandwagon, without
regard for its purposes or consequences, because they see it as a fast
(and sometimes interesting) way to make a buck. It has also been
suggested that some of those people who promote ADR as a means
* Circuit Judge, United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit. Cornell
University, B.S., 1962; University of Michigan, J.D., x965. The author wishes to acknowledge
the research assistance given him by Charles Blanchard in the preparation of this Commentary.
1 Edelman, Institutionalizing Dispute Resolution Alternatives, 9 JUST. SYS. J. 134, 136
(1984).
2 Sixteen states and ten federal district courts have authorized court-ordered arbitration
programs. See Background and Status, DISPUTE RESOLUTION F., Aug. i985, at 4.