About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



69 Md. L. Rev. 791 (2009-2010)
The Importance of Being Ambiguous: Substantive Canons, Stare Decisis, and the Central Role of Ambiguity Determinations in the Administrative State

handle is hein.journals/mllr69 and id is 799 raw text is: MARYLAND LAW REVIEW

VOLUME 69                           2010                          NUMBER 4
© Copyright Maryland Law Review 2010
Articles
THE IMPORTANCE OF BEING AMBIGUOUS: SUBSTANTIVE
CANONS, STARE DECISIS, AND THE CENTRAL ROLE
OF AMBIGUITY DETERMINATIONS IN THE
ADMINISTRATIVE STATE
BRIAN G. SLOCUM*
ABSTRACT
The concept of ambiguity plays an underappreciated and un-
dertheorized role in the judicial review of agency statutory interpreta-
tions. Its importance is difficult to exaggerate. Ambiguity often
functions as the determiner of whether an agency's statutory interpre-
tation will receive deference, as well as whether courts will apply the
stare decisis standard for statutory interpretation cases instead of the
recent principle that agencies can change their interpretations even
in the face of a previous conflicting judicial interpretation. The
prominence of ambiguity has caused many commentators and courts
to proclaim a bright line distinction between interpretive tools that
help evaluate statutory clarity and those that resolve statutory uncer-
tainty. Although linguists would agree that ambiguity is unexcep-
tional in normative legal texts due to its ubiquity, the judiciary,
which has created a highly idiosyncratic definition, is far more selec-
tive about declaring language to be ambiguous. The judiciary's se-
lectivity regarding ambiguity is driven by its conflation of ambiguity
Copyright © 2010 by Brian G. Slocum.
* Associate Professor of Law, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law.
J.D., Harvard Law School, 1999. The author would like to thank Steve Calandrillo, Miriam
Cherry, Omar Dajani, Scott Dodson, Brian Foley, LindaJellum, Stephen Legomsky, Thom
Main, David L. Shapiro, Ted Sichelman, John Sprankling, Jarrod Wong, and the partici-
pants at a faculty workshop at McGeorge School of Law for their valuable comments on an
earlier draft of this Article.