About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



43 S. Cal. L. Rev. 597 (1970)
The Fifth Amendment Privilege against Self-Incrimination: Extorting Physical Evidence from a Suspect

handle is hein.journals/scal43 and id is 613 raw text is: THE FIFTH AMENDMENT
PRIVILEGE AGAINST SELF-
INCRIMINATION: EXTORTING
PHYSICAL EVIDENCE FROM A
SUSPECT
B. MICHAEL DANN*
INTRODUCTION
The fifth amendment privilege against self-incrimination prohibits
compelling a criminal suspect or defendant . . . to be a witness against
himself ... There are, however, many theories as to which types of
accused originating evidence should be granted the protection of the
privilege.' The most widely accepted theory is that advocated by the late
Dean Wigmore which affords the protection of the privilege only to
statements extracted from the person's own lips.'3 The Wigmorean
orthodoxy, as this theory has been called4 has been reflected in the
recent Supreme Court decision of Schmerber v. California5 and its
subsequent progeny.' In holding that the privilege against self-
incrimination does not protect the accused from compulsory blood tests,
the Court established the distinction between real evidence, such as
blood which is not protected, and testimonial evidence, such as oral
or written confessions which is protected.
Almost without exception,7 courts and commentators have accepted
Schmerber and its progeny without criticism or question. It is believed,
* Member of the Arizona Bar. B.S. 1961, Indiana University, LL.B. cum laude, Harvard
Law School.
I. U.S. CONST., amend. V.
2. 8 J. Wigmore, Evidence, § 2250 at 267-295, § 2263 at 378-79 (McNaughton Rev. 1961).
3. 8 J. WIGMORE, EVIDENCE § 2263, at 262-63 (3d ed. 1940) (emphasis in original)
[hereinafter referred to as WIGMORE].
4. The phrase Wigmorean orthodoxy is borrowed from Louisell, Criminal Discovery and
Self-Incrimination, 53 CALIF. L. REV. 89,97 n. 33 (1965).
5. 384 U.S. 436 (1966).
6. 3See United States v. Wade, 388 U.S. 218 (1967) (no violation of the fifth amendment
privilege against self-incrimination occurs when the accused is forced to give a voice sample);
Gilbert v. California, 388 U.S. 263 (1967) (no violation of the fifth amendment privilege occurs
when the accused is compelled to supply a handwriting exemplar); cf. Warden v. Hayden, 387 U.S.
294, 302-03 (1967) (no violation of fifth amendment privilege when police seize mere evidenciary
materials such as clothing).
7. See The Supreme Court, 1966 Term, 81 HARV. L. REV. 69, 116017 (1967); Comment, 1967
DUKE L.J. 366, 382 n. 98 (1967); Note, Constitutional Law-Self-Incrimination--Search and