About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



12 J. Intell. Prop. Info. Tech. & Elec. Com. L. 370 (2021)
Competition Problems and Governance of Non-Personal Agricultural Machine Data: Comparing Voluntary Initiatives in the US and EU

handle is hein.journals/jipitec12 and id is 382 raw text is: Can Atik and Bertin Martens

Competition Problems and Governance of Non-
personal Agricultural Machine Data: Comparing
Voluntary Initiatives in the US and EU
by Can Atik and Bertin Martens'

Abstract:     The arrival of digital data in agricu-
ture opens the possibility to realise productivity gains
through precision farming. It also raises questions
about the distribution of these gains between farm-
ers and agricultural service providers. Farmers' con-
trol of the data is often perceived as a means to ap-
propriate a larger share of these gains. We show how
data-driven agricultural business models lock farm
data into machines and devices that reduce compe-
tition in downstream agricultural services markets.
Personal data protection regulation is not applicable
to non-personal agricultural machine data. /olun-
tary data charters in the EU and US emulate GDPR-
like principles to give farmers more control over their
data but do not really change market-based out-
comes due to their legal design. Third-party plat-
forms are a necessary intermediary because farmers
cannot achieve the benefits from applications that
depend on economies of scale and scope in data ag-
gregation. Data lock-in, combined with the low mar-

ginal value of individual farm data, puts farmers in
a weak bargaining position. Neutral intermediar-
ies that are not vertically integrated into agricultural
machines, inputs or services may help farmers to cir-
cumvent monopolistic data lock-ins. However, unless
these neutral intermediaries find a way to generate
and monetise economies of scale and scope with
their data, their business model may not be sustain-
able. Regulatory intervention thatfacilitates portabi-
ity and interoperability might be useful for farmers
to overcome data lock-ins, but designing data access
rights is a complicated issue as many parties con-
tribute data in the production process and may claim
access rights. Minor changes in who gets access to
which data under which conditions may have signif-
icant effects on stakeholders. We conclude that dig-
ital agriculture still has some way to go to reach eq-
uitable and efficient solutions to data access rights.
Similar situations are likely to occur in other indus-
tries that rely on non-personal machine data.

© 2021 Can Atik and Bertin Martens
Everybody may disseminate this article by electronic means and make it available for download under the terms and
conditions of the Digital Peer Publishing Licence (DPPL). A copy of the license text may be obtained at http://nbn-resolving.
de/urn:nbn:de:0009-dppl-v3-en8.
Recommended citation: Can Atik and Bertin Martens, Competition Problems and Governance of Non-personal Agricultural
Machine Data: Comparing Voluntary Initiatives in the US and EU, 12 (2021) JIPITEC 370 para 1
A. Introduction

1   In conventional agriculture, decisions on farm
inputs and processes are taken by farmers, based on
their personal know-how. Today, the introduction
of sensor-based digital data, Internet-of-Things
(IoT) technologies and big data analytics in Smart
Farming or Digital Agriculture' result in machine-
*    Can Atik is a PhD candidate at Tilburg Law School with affil-
iation to the Tilburg Law and Economics Center (TILEC) and
Tilburg Institute for Law, Technology, and Society (TILT),

5037 DE Tilburg, the Netherlands. The PhD research is funded
by the postgraduate scholarship program of the Ministry of
National Education, Republic of Turkey. Bertin Martens is
Senior economist at the Joint Research Centre of the European
Commission, E-41092 Seville, Spain. The views and opinions ex-
pressed in this paper are the authors' and do not necessarily reflect
those of theJoint Research Centre or the European Commission
1    Xuan Pham and Martin Stack, 'How data analytics is transform-
ing agriculture' (2018) 61 Business Horizons, p. 127; Harald
Sundmaeker and others, 'Internet of food and farm 2020' in
Ovidiu Vermesan and Peter Friess (eds), Digitising the Industry

3   jipitec

370

2021