About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



95 Colum. L. Rev. 1001 (1995)
Issue 5

handle is hein.journals/clr95 and id is 1011 raw text is: COLUMBIA LAW REVIEW
VOL. 95                      JUNE 1995                         NO. 5
STATE SOVEREIGNTY AND SUBORDINACY: MAY
CONGRESS COMMANDEER STATE OFFICERS TO
IMPLEMENT FEDERAL LAW?
Evan H. Caminker*
Introduction
I. Visions of Sovereignty and Subordinacy ..................... 1008
A. States as Subordinate Agents of the Federal
Government ...........................................  1009
B. States as Sovereign Entities: Emergence of the New
Autonomy Model of Federalism ........................ 1015
II. Squaring State Autonomy with Federal Supremacy: The
Lesson of State Court Commandeering ..................... 1022
A. Supremacy Principles and the Federal Commandeering
of State Actors  ........................................  1022
1. The Supremacy Clause as the Basis of Federal
Commandeering of State Courts ................... 1022
2. The Principles Underlying State Court
Commandeering Are Generalizable to All State
Actors  .............................................  1028
B. Textual Arguments Against Nonjudicial
Commandeering ...................................... 1030
1. What the Text Does and Does Not Say ............. 1031
2. The Judges Clause ................................. 1034
C. The Framers' Intent Regarding Nonjudicial
Commandeering ...................................... 1042
D. Commandeering Authority and Formal Distinctions
Between Lawmaking and Law Enforcement . ...... 1050
1. Special Features of the Judicial Enterprise .......... 1050
2. State Control over Lawmaking ..................... 1053
III. Normative Objections to Nonjudicial Commandeering ...... 1060
A. Shifting Political Liability from Federal to State
Officials ...............................................  1061
* Acting Professor, U.C.LA School of Law. BA. 1983, U.C.L.A.; J.D. 1986, Yale
University. I gratefully acknowledge helpful suggestions from Vik Amar, Erwin
Chemerinsky, Craig Goldblatt, Robert Goldstein, and numerous colleagues participating at
a paper presentation to the U.C.LA faculty. I also thank Matthew Erramouspe and
Elizabeth Horton for valuable research assistance.

1001