About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



62 Buff. L. Rev. 1159 (2014)
A Rational Theory of Mitigation and Aggravation in Sentencing: Why Less is More When It Comes to Punishing Criminals

handle is hein.journals/buflr62 and id is 1199 raw text is: A Rational Theory of Mitigation and
Aggravation in Sentencing: Why Less is More
When it Comes to Punishing Criminals
MIRKO BAGARICt
INTRODUCTION
Sentencing involves the intentional infliction of pain.' It
is the legal domain where the state acts in its most forceful
manner against individuals. It is important that the
sentencing system is fair and effective. Unfortunately, this is
not the case. In the sentencing arena there is a gulf between
knowledge and practice. Sentencing is a politicized domain,
and hence, law and practice are often detached from
knowledge. This is evident in four key areas of sentencing
policy and practice.
Most broadly, it relates to the ongoing uncertainty
regarding which theory of punishment should underpin the
system. Retributivism has replaced utilitarianism as the
most popular contemporary theory of punishment;2 however,
the change has not heavily impacted legislative and judicial
developments and certainly traditional utilitarian aims
continue to heavily influence sentencing practice and policy.
Secondly, a lack of empirical and scientific certainty remains
regarding the efficacy of state-imposed punishment to
achieve key (utilitarian) goals of sentencing in the form of
incapacitation, general deterrence, specific deterrence, and
rehabilitation.3 Moreover, to the extent that convergence
exists regarding the efficacy of sentencing to attain these
t Professor and Dean of Law, Deakin University, Melbourne.
1. See JEREMY BENTHAM, AN INTRODUCTION TO THE PRINCIPLES OF MORALS AND
LEGISLATION 158-59 (J.H. Burns & H.L.A. Hart eds., 1970); C.L. TEN, CRIME
GUILT, AND PUNISHMENT 2 (1987).
2. See Mirko Bagaric & Kumar Amarasekara, The Errors of Retributivism, 24
MELB. U. L. REV. 124, 131-33 (2000) [hereinafter Bagaric & Amarasekara, The
Errors of Retributivism].
3. See infra Part VI.

1159